Nedarim 60

Here is a Jewish parenting lesson inspired by Nedarim 60, focusing on the concept of "growths" and exceptions, adapted for busy parents.

The Beauty of "Good Enough" Growths in Parenting

Insight

Life with children is rarely a perfectly manicured garden. More often, it feels like a vibrant, sometimes chaotic, patch of earth where things sprout unexpectedly, change shape, and sometimes grow in ways we didn't anticipate. The Talmudic discussion in Nedarim 60, though ostensibly about agricultural laws and vows, offers a profound metaphor for navigating the messy, beautiful reality of raising children. It grapples with the idea of "growths" – things that emerge from a primary source – and whether these growths inherit the status (and restrictions) of their origin, or if they can, under certain conditions, be considered separate and even permitted.

In our parenting journey, the "primary source" is our intention, our rules, our carefully laid plans for our children. The "growths" are the myriad ways our children express themselves, the unexpected turns their development takes, the unintended consequences of our parenting decisions, and the sometimes surprising ways they interpret our guidance. We might intend to teach our child about generosity, and the "growth" might be an overly enthusiastic sharing that leaves them with nothing for themselves. We might set a boundary for safety, and the "growth" could be a child’s creative (and sometimes frustrating) attempt to test that boundary in a new way. The key insight from Nedarim 60, especially through the lens of Rabbi Yannai and the discussions around "growths of growths," is that not everything that emerges from a primary intention or rule needs to be treated with the same level of strictness. Just as certain "growths" in the Talmud are deemed permissible, even if the original produce was sacred or forbidden, so too can we learn to identify and embrace the "growths" in our parenting that are permissible, even "good enough," and perhaps even beneficial, despite not being exactly what we initially envisioned.

This isn't about lowering our standards or abandoning our values. Rather, it's about developing a nuanced perspective. The Gemara discusses how "growths of growths" can sometimes be permitted, especially when they become abundant or distinct from the original. This mirrors how a child's behavior, initially a direct reaction to a rule or expectation, can evolve into something more complex. A child's initial resistance to sharing might grow into a nuanced understanding of personal boundaries and the value of negotiation. A child's initial struggle with a concept might "grow" into a unique approach to problem-solving. Our role as parents, like the rabbinic sages, is to discern when these "growths" are acceptable exceptions, when they are simply part of the natural unfolding of life, and when they require our gentle redirection. The danger, as the Talmud warns, is to be so rigid in our adherence to the "primary source" that we fail to see the permissible or even positive developments that have sprouted from it. This can lead to unnecessary conflict and a stifling of natural growth.

The concept of "majority" also plays a role in the Talmudic discussion – if the "growths" outnumber the original, the original can become permitted. In parenting, this can be understood as the cumulative positive experiences or developmental milestones that outweigh a single moment of challenge or deviation. If a child generally exhibits kindness and responsibility, a single instance of selfishness or carelessness shouldn't necessarily define them or invalidate all their positive attributes. We are often encouraged to look at the "majority" of a child's behavior and character. Furthermore, the text highlights the distinction between things whose "seeds cease" and those whose "seeds do not cease." This can be interpreted as the difference between behaviors that are temporary and those that seem more ingrained. Our response to a fleeting tantrum, for instance, might differ significantly from our response to a recurring pattern of defiance. Recognizing these distinctions allows for a more tailored and empathetic approach. The ultimate takeaway from this complex discussion is not about finding loophole; it's about cultivating wisdom and flexibility. It's about understanding that life, and especially life with children, is a dynamic process. We are called to be both grounded in our principles and open to the unexpected blossoming that can occur when we allow for a little bit of "good enough" growth. This perspective shift can alleviate immense pressure, allowing us to celebrate the small victories and navigate the inevitable challenges with greater peace and presence. By embracing this nuanced understanding, we can move from a place of striving for perfection to a place of appreciating the beautiful, imperfect, and ever-growing tapestry of our family life.

Text Snapshot

"Rabbi Yannai permits the teruma, not due to the majority of direct growths of teruma; he permitted it due to the majority of growths that sprouted from its growths. The Gemara asks: We have already learned that too: The status of growths of growths of teruma is that of non-sacred produce. The Gemara answers: This teaches us that the growths of growths are permitted even in items whose seeds do not cease, e.g., onions."

Nedarim 60a

Activity

The "Sprouting Ideas" Jar: Cultivating Permissible Growths

This activity helps families recognize and celebrate the "growths" in their daily lives, distinguishing between what needs strict adherence and what can be considered a permissible, even positive, deviation.

For Toddlers (Ages 2-4)

Activity: "My Happy Flower"

• Goal: To introduce the idea that good things can come from unexpected places, and that "almost right" is often wonderful.
• Materials: Large piece of paper, crayons or markers, stickers (flowers, sun, happy faces).
• Time: 5-7 minutes

How-to:

1. Draw a simple stem and a few leaves on the paper.
2. Say: "We're going to make a happy flower! Sometimes, flowers grow in funny ways, but they still become beautiful."
3. Start drawing a circle for the flower head. You can draw it slightly crooked or not perfectly round. Say: "Uh oh, my flower is a little wobbly! Is it still a flower?" (Encourage a "yes!") "It's a wobbly flower! That's okay!"
4. Have your child add petals. They might draw them unevenly or in odd numbers. Say: "Wow, look at all those petals! Some are big, some are small. Our flower is so unique!"
5. Let your child add stickers for the center of the flower, or for other decorations.
6. As you add elements, point out the "growths": "Look, this petal grew a little extra long! That's a fun growth!" or "This sticker grew right on the stem! It’s part of our happy flower!"
7. Conclude by saying: "Our flower isn't perfect, but it's so happy and beautiful! It's a wonderful, wobbly, unique flower!"

For Elementary Schoolers (Ages 5-10)

Activity: "The 'Oops, I Did It Again' Story"

• Goal: To help children understand that mistakes or unexpected outcomes can sometimes lead to good things, and that we can learn from them.

• Materials: A notebook or a few sheets of paper, pens/pencils.
• Time: 8-10 minutes

How-to:

1. Gather your child and say: "Let's play a game called 'Oops, I Did It Again!' It’s about those times when something doesn't go exactly as planned, but then something good happens anyway."
2. Ask your child to think of a time they tried to do something, and it didn't turn out perfectly, but something positive came from it. (e.g., "I tried to bake cookies, and they got a little burnt, but they tasted like toffee!" or "I forgot my homework at home, but then I remembered I had an extra copy in my backpack.")
3. If they struggle, offer a simple example: "Once, when I was trying to make a sandwich, I accidentally dropped a piece of cheese on the floor. I was sad, but then I realized that piece of cheese looked really funny, so I drew a cartoon character on it and it made me laugh!"
4. Write down the "mistake" or unexpected outcome, and then write down the "good growth" that came from it.
5. You can also share your own "Oops, I Did It Again" story from your childhood or even from your day.
6. Frame it as: "See? Even when things don't go perfectly, sometimes wonderful new things can grow from it. It's like the 'growths of growths' in the Talmud – something new and interesting happens!"
7. Keep a running list in the notebook. You can revisit it when things don't go as planned.

For Tweens and Teens (Ages 11+)

Activity: "The 'Unintended Consequence' Brainstorm"

• Goal: To encourage critical thinking about how actions can have multiple outcomes, and to identify positive "growths" from less-than-ideal starting points.
• Materials: Whiteboard or large paper, markers.
• Time: 10 minutes

How-to:

1. Start by introducing the concept: "Today, we're going to talk about 'unintended consequences.' Sometimes, when we set out to do something, or when something happens, there are ripple effects or 'growths' that we didn't expect. Some might be negative, but some can actually be really positive."
2. Choose a common scenario or a hypothetical situation. Examples:
   • "You wanted to sleep in on Saturday, but your alarm didn't go off, and you woke up super early."
   • "You were trying to finish a project, and you made a mistake that set you back."
   • "You decided to try a new hobby that turned out to be harder than you thought."
3. On the board, write the initial situation or intention. Then, brainstorm the direct (and perhaps negative) consequences.
4. Next, brainstorm the "growths" – the unintended, often positive, outcomes. For example, if the alarm didn't go off and they woke up early:
   • Initial intention: Sleep in.
   • Direct consequence: Woke up early, missed sleep.
   • "Growths": "I had quiet time to read," "I got a head start on my chores," "I saw the sunrise," "I realized I can function on less sleep than I thought," "I learned to set a backup alarm."
5. Discuss which "growths" are valuable and how recognizing them can shift perspective. Relate it back to the Talmudic idea that not all "growths" are to be treated with the same strictness; some are even beneficial.
6. Encourage them to think about their own lives and identify similar "growths."

Script

Scenario: Your child does something that you explicitly asked them not to do, but their reasoning or the outcome is unexpectedly positive or understandable.

Awkward Question: "But I thought you said [rule/instruction]! Why are you okay with this now?"

---

Script 1 (For younger children):

Parent: "Hey, sweetie! I see you went ahead and [did the thing you asked them not to do]. I remember I asked you not to do that, and I was expecting you to [explain the original expectation]."

Child: "But [explain their reasoning/unexpected positive outcome]."

Parent: "You know what? You're right. That's a really good point. I asked you not to do it because of [original reason]. But you took that idea, and it grew into something different, didn't it? It grew into you [explain the positive outcome/reasoning]. That's a really smart way to think. It's like a little 'growth' of an idea, and this growth is actually a good one! So, while I still need you to listen to my instructions about [original reason], I'm also really impressed with how you thought about this. We can learn from each other, can't we?"

---

Script 2 (For older children/teens):

Parent: "So, I noticed you did [action]. My initial instruction was about [briefly restate instruction and original reason]. My expectation was that you would [state expected action]."

Child: "Yeah, but I was trying to [explain their reasoning/unexpected positive outcome]."

Parent: "Okay, I hear you. And I appreciate you explaining that. The rule about [original instruction] is important because of [reinforce original reason]. However, I can see how your approach here, which is a kind of 'growth' from the initial situation, led to [acknowledge the positive outcome/reasoning]. It's a bit like how in the Talmud, sometimes things that sprout from an original rule can be seen differently, especially if they lead to something good or unexpected. What this shows me is that you're thinking, you're problem-solving. For this specific instance, I'm going to accept the outcome because of [reason you're accepting it, e.g., the positive result]. Going forward, though, it's still important to either check in with me before you make a significant change to a rule, or to make sure your 'growth' of an idea still aligns with the core principle of [original reason]."

---

Script 3 (When you need to reinforce the original rule but acknowledge their effort):

Parent: "I saw you [did the thing]. My instruction was about [instruction and reason]. I know you're really good at thinking outside the box, and I love that about you. That's a wonderful 'growth' of your thinking. However, in this particular situation, the reason I said [instruction] was really important for [reiterate core reason]. So, even though your idea was creative, we still need to follow the original instruction here. Can you help me understand what you were trying to achieve with your idea? Maybe we can find another way to do that in the future."

---

Script 4 (When the "growth" is genuinely helpful and you can adapt):

Parent: "You know, I asked you not to [do X] because of [reason Y]. But you went ahead and [did Z] instead, and I can see that [explain the positive outcome/how Z addressed the core issue]. That's actually a brilliant 'growth' from my original instruction! You took the spirit of what I was trying to accomplish and found a better way. I'm really impressed. Thank you for thinking so creatively and for still respecting the underlying reason. From now on, if something like this comes up, we can consider [new approach] as a valid option."

Habit

Micro-Habit: "The 'What Grew?' Check-in"

This week, commit to one small, daily moment of reflection. At the end of the day, or during a quiet moment with your child, ask a simple question: "What's something new or unexpected that 'grew' today?"

This could be:

• A new skill they learned.
• A surprising idea they had.
• An unexpected way a situation turned out.
• A funny moment or observation.
• A different way they approached a task.

The goal isn't to analyze or fix anything, but simply to acknowledge the "growths" – the natural, emergent aspects of life and learning. You can write it down, draw it, or just say it aloud. This practice cultivates an awareness of the dynamic and often beautiful processes that unfold in your family life, fostering a mindset of flexibility and appreciation for "good enough" developments.

Takeaway

Life with children is a garden of unexpected sprouts. Instead of striving for a perfectly pruned, uniform landscape, let's learn to appreciate the "growths" – the emergent behaviors, ideas, and outcomes that may not have been part of the original plan. By recognizing that not every deviation is a problem, and that some "growths" can even be beneficial, we can parent with more grace, flexibility, and joy, celebrating the beautiful, imperfect, and ever-evolving tapestry of our families. Embrace the "good enough" growths; they are often where the real learning and love flourish.