Menachot 11

Sugya Map

• Issue: Defining the precise measure and method of kemitza (scooping the handful) for a Mincha offering.
• Nafka Mina(s): Determines the kasher (fit) or pasul (unfit) status of the Mincha, with implications for karet if piggul or notar.
• Primary Sources: Vayikra 2:2 ("וקמץ"), Vayikra 6:8 ("מלא קומצו"), Mishna Menachot 11a, Gemara Menachot 11a.

Text Snapshot

The Gemara clarifies the kemitza process: "אי בקמצו יכול בראשי אצבעותיו תלמוד לומר מלא קמצו הא כיצד חופה שלש אצבעותיו על פס ידו וקומץ" (Menachot 11a).

• Dikduk/Leshon Nuance: The juxtaposition of "בקמצו" (with his handful) implying the action or instrument of scooping, with "מלא קומצו" (his full handful) emphasizing the quantity. The resolution via "הא כיצד?" (How so?) highlights the interpretive synthesis needed.

Readings

• Rashi: Defines "בראשי אצבעותיו" as "מעט שלא יגיע עד פס ידו" (a small amount that does not reach the palm of his hand)¹, emphasizing the lack of fullness if only fingertips are used.
• Rashba: Elaborates on the derasha, explaining that "בקמצו" might suggest any handful, even a shallow one. "מלא קומצו" then demands fullness. The method of "חופה שלש אצבעותיו על פס ידו" (folding three fingers over his palm) is the derech shaveh (balanced approach) that reconciles both scriptural demands.²

Friction

• Kushya: Why does the Torah use two seemingly redundant phrases, "וקמץ" and "מלא קומצו," to describe the kometz?
• Terutz: As the Gemara and Rishonim elucidate, "בקמצו" denotes the act of scooping with the hand, potentially implying even a partial measure (e.g., with fingertips). "מלא קומצו" then adds the crucial qualifier of fullness. The precise method of "חופה שלש אצבעותיו על פס ידו" serves as the halachic synthesis, ensuring the kometz is both scooped by hand and fully measured.

Intertext

The importance of precise kemitza extends beyond Mincha. Rav Pappa raises similar she'eilot regarding the kometz of ketoret (incense) on Yom Kippur, specifically concerning scooping methods (e.g., "בראשי אצבעותיו" or "מן הצדדין"), underscoring the universal demand for exactitude in avodah. (Menachot 11b).

Psak/Practice

The halacha follows the meticulous method of scooping with three fingers folded onto the palm, then leveling with the thumb and pinky. This reflects a foundational principle in avodat HaMikdash: even minute deviations from prescribed action or measure render the offering pasul.

Takeaway

The meticulous sugya on kemitza reveals the Torah's profound demand for precision in avodat HaMikdash, where seemingly minor details bear significant halachic weight, symbolizing the gravity of approaching the Divine.

---

¹ Rashi, Menachot 11a s.v. בראשי אצבעותיו. ² Rashba (Attributed), Menachot 11a s.v. אי בקומצו יכול בראשי אצבעותיו.