Mishneh Torah, Blessings 10-11

Sugya Map

• Issue

  The Rambam's classification of "other blessings and many other statements" (ברכות אחרות ודברים רבים) in Mishneh Torah, Blessings 10:1, which often deviate from the standard p'tichah (opening formula) and chatimah (closing formula) of typical brachot.

• Nafka Mina

  Understanding the scope and definition of birkat Hashem (blessing God), distinguishing these expressions of praise and acknowledgement (שבח והודיה) from birkat hanehenin (blessings over enjoyment) or birkat hamitzvot (blessings over mitzvah performance), and their respective halachic implications.

• Primary Sources

  Mishneh Torah, Blessings 10:1 and 10:13; Berachot 12a; Rambam, Hilchot Tefillah 1:7.

Text Snapshot

"הסנהדרין התקינו ברכות אחרות ודברים רבים שאין בהן פתיחה ולא חתימה, דרך שבח והודיה להקדוש ברוך הוא, כגון ברכות התפילה שכתבנום כבר."¹ Dikduk/Leshon: The juxtaposition of "ברכות אחרות" (other blessings) and "ודברים רבים" (and many other statements) suggests a broader, less formally structured category of divine acknowledgement. The phrase "שאין בהן פתיחה ולא חתימה" implies a deviation from the dual-formulaic structure, either by lacking one or both elements.

Readings

• Steinsaltz on Mishneh Torah, Blessings 10:1 s.v. ודברים שאין בהן פתיחה ולא חתימה

  Defines these as "אמירות ללא הנוסח 'ברוך אתה ה'...' בתחילתן ובסופן" (Statements without the formula 'Blessed are You, God...' at their beginning and end), highlighting their structural irregularity.

• Steinsaltz on Mishneh Torah, Blessings 10:1 s.v. דרך שבח והודיה

  Emphasizes their purpose: "ולא ברכה על הנאה או על מצווה" (And not a blessing over enjoyment or a mitzvah), underscoring their distinct function as pure expressions of "שבח והודיה" (praise and acknowledgement).

Friction

• Kushya

  If "blessings" (ברכות) are halachically defined by their p'tichah and chatimah (Berachot 12a; Rambam, Hilchot Tefillah 1:7), how can the Rambam in 10:1 introduce "other blessings" that explicitly lack these foundational elements? It seems an oxymoron.

• Terutz

  The Rambam employs "ברכה" here in a broader, conceptual sense of acknowledging God's greatness, distinct from the technical birkat hanehenin or birkat hamitzvot. These are acts of שבח והודיה, and thus, as Steinsaltz notes, are not bound by the same structural rules. Their varied forms, some lacking p'tichah, some chatimah, and some both, are detailed later in MT 10:13.

Intertext

• Berachot 12a: "כל ברכות שבתורה פותח בברוך וחותם בברוך, חוץ מברכת המזון..." This Gemara provides the foundational principle for ptichah and chatimah in rabbinic blessings, thereby contextualizing the Rambam's discussion in 10:1 as addressing a unique class of brachot that operate outside this standard.

Psak/Practice

This distinction informs our understanding of the parameters of bracha levatalah (a blessing in vain). While all "blessings" require kavanah, statements of pure שבח והודיה that lack the full ptichah/chatimah may have a different halachic status than formal birkat hanehenin regarding the utterance of Shem u'Malchut. The meta-psak heuristic is to appreciate the diverse modes of birkat Hashem while maintaining reverence for each.

Takeaway

The Rambam broadens our understanding of what constitutes a "blessing," revealing that profound divine acknowledgement transcends rigid formal structures and embraces varied expressions of praise and gratitude.

---

¹ Mishneh Torah, Blessings 10:1. Full text available at https://www.sefaria.org/Mishneh_Torah%2C_Blessings_10-11.