Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chayim 134:2-135:2

Absolutely! Here is a 15-minute introductory lesson on the foundations of Judaism, focusing on the provided text from the Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chayim 134:2-135:2. I've aimed for clarity, empathy, and a structure that builds understanding.

---

The Big Question

Welcome, everyone, to our journey into the heart of Jewish practice and tradition. Today, we're going to explore some fascinating details about how we engage with the Torah, particularly during communal prayer services.

Think about a time you've felt a deep sense of reverence or awe. Perhaps it was witnessing a breathtaking natural wonder, listening to powerful music, or experiencing a moment of profound connection with others. What made that experience so impactful? Often, it's about the way we engage our senses, our emotions, and our minds. It's about rituals, symbols, and shared moments that elevate the ordinary into something extraordinary.

In Judaism, the Torah is the central text, the very word of God as received by the Jewish people. It's not just a book; it's a living, breathing guide for life. So, how do we ensure that our engagement with this sacred text is meaningful, reverent, and impactful for everyone in the community, from the most learned scholar to someone just beginning their journey?

Today, we'll delve into a passage from the Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chayim 134:2-135:2. This text, written centuries ago by Rabbi Joseph Karo, codifies Jewish law and practice. It offers us a glimpse into the meticulous details of how synagogues around the world have traditionally prepared for, performed, and concluded readings from the Torah. We'll explore the significance of specific prayers, the order of who is called to read, and even the physical handling of the Torah scroll itself. By understanding these practices, we can begin to appreciate the depth of intention and community that underpins Jewish life.

My goal today is not to overwhelm you with legalistic minutiae, but rather to illuminate the why behind these customs. We'll discover how these seemingly small details contribute to a profound collective experience, fostering reverence, unity, and a deeper connection to the Divine and to each other. Let's embark on this exploration together.

One Core Concept

The core concept we'll explore today is the communal engagement with the Torah scroll as a sacred act of reverence and education. This involves not just the act of reading, but the entire process surrounding it – the preparations, the physical presentation of the scroll, the order of participation, and the accompanying prayers. It emphasizes that the Torah is a shared heritage, and its public engagement is a mitzvah (commandment) for the entire community, men and women alike.

Breaking It Down

This section will meticulously unpack the provided text from the Shulchan Arukh, explaining each component in an accessible way.

The "V'hu Rachum" Prayer and Lifting the Torah (Orach Chayim 134:2-4)

Our passage begins by discussing a prayer called "V'hu Rachum," which is recited on Mondays and Thursdays.

### The Practice of "V'hu Rachum"

• What it is: "V'hu Rachum" (meaning "He is Merciful") is a prayer that is recited as an additional supplication. The custom is to increase these supplications on Mondays and Thursdays.
• Why these days? The text, citing the Tur (a medieval legal codifier), explains that Mondays and Thursdays are considered days of "Divine favor." This means they are seen as particularly opportune times for prayer and for receiving Divine mercy. Because of this, there's also a custom to fast on these days, further emphasizing their spiritual significance.
• How it's said: The practice is to say "V'hu Rachum" while standing. The Glosses add an interesting nuance here. One gloss states that if one didn't say it while standing, it's considered transgressing a rabbinic enactment, referred to as "breaching a fence." However, another gloss clarifies that while the practice is to say it standing, it's often said quietly. This highlights a tension between the ideal enactment and common practice, with the emphasis on not completely disregarding the standing requirement.

### Showing the Torah Scroll

This section is particularly vivid and descriptive. It details the physical act of presenting the Torah scroll to the congregation.

• The Ritual: When the Torah scroll is taken out, the person holding it is instructed to show the writing of the scroll to those standing to their right and left. Then, they turn it to face those in front and behind.
• The Purpose: This is not just a perfunctory gesture. The text declares it a mitzvah for all men and women to see the writing and to bow and recite a specific declaration: "V'zot Hatorah... Torat Hashem Temima" ("And this is the Torah... Hashem's Torah is Perfect").
• Deeper Meaning (Magen Avraham & Ba'er Hetev): The commentary from Magen Avraham and Ba'er Hetev adds layers of understanding.
  • Magen Avraham, citing the Maharil (a prominent medieval rabbi), explains that the practice of people rushing to the synagogue to see the Torah being taken out and returned, even when they might stand outside during other parts of the service, is rooted in the principle of "B'rov Am Hadrat Melech" – "In the multitude of people is the King's glory." This means the gathering of many people in reverence enhances God's glory.
  • Ba'er Hetev elaborates on the act of seeing the writing. It explains that looking closely at the letters until one can read them brings "great light" (drawing from Kabbalistic concepts). The act of rolling the scroll and holding it up to be seen is specifically mentioned.
  • Magen Avraham also notes that one should hold the Torah on their right side.
• "Gad'lu" and "Av Harachamim": The Ashkenazic custom, as noted in the glosses, is to say "Gad'lu" (Exalt!) after the Torah reading, with the congregation responding "Romemu..." ("Exalt Him..."). Following this, the prayer "Av Harachamim Hu Yeracheim Am Amusim" ("May the Father of mercy have compassion on the people borne by Him") is recited. Some also say "Al Hakol Yit'gadal," a practice observed on Yom Tov and Shabbat.
• "Baruch Sh'natan Torah": When the first person is called up to read from the Torah (known as receiving an aliyah), they recite the blessing "Baruch Sh'natan Torah" ("Blessed is the One who gave the Torah"). Magen Avraham notes that this blessing is followed by "Al Hatorah v'al ha'avodah v'al hag'ulah v'al ha'tzedakah." The commentary mentions that the phrase "Al Hatorah" itself contains 40 letters, corresponding to the 40 days Moses spent on Mount Sinai.

The Order of Reading from the Torah on Monday and Thursday (Orach Chayim 135:1-16)

This section, comprising 14 segments (s'ifim), details the practical organization of Torah readings.

### The Basic Structure of Readings

• How Many Read: On Monday, Thursday, and Shabbat afternoon (mincha), three people are called to read from the Torah.
• No Additions or Subtractions: The text is clear: "we don't subtract from them or add to them." This implies a fixed structure for these readings.
• No Haftarah: Importantly, on these days, the reading of the Prophets (haftarah) does not follow the Torah reading. The focus is solely on the Torah itself.

### Exceptions for Special Occasions

• Multiple Grooms or Brit Milah: The glosses introduce an interesting exception. If there are two grooms in the synagogue, or for two officiants of a brit milah (circumcision ceremony), it is permitted to add a fourth aliyah.
• Reasoning: The rationale is that these occasions are considered like a "Festival" for those involved, during which it is permissible to add readings. This highlights how communal joy and significant life events can expand the established norms to accommodate spiritual needs. The text also references chapter 559 and chapter 282 for further details on additions during festivals and Shabbat.

### Continuity of Torah Readings

• Where to Begin: The place where the reading stopped on Shabbat morning dictates where the reading will begin on Shabbat afternoon (mincha), on Monday, Thursday, and the following Shabbat morning.
• Catching Up: If a community missed the public reading of a parashah (weekly Torah portion) on one Shabbat, the following Shabbat they will read that missed parashah along with the parashah that belongs to that week. This ensures that the entire Torah is covered systematically.

### The Hierarchy of Aliyot

This is a crucial aspect of the text, outlining the established order of who is called for an aliyah.

• The Standard Order: The established order is:
  1. A Kohen (priest)
  2. A Levite
  3. An Israelite (anyone not a Kohen or Levite)
• The Unlearned Kohen: The custom is that even a Kohen who is not highly learned in Torah will read before a great scholar who is an Israelite, as long as the Kohen knows how to read. This emphasizes the inherent sanctity of the priestly lineage for the first aliyah. The condition is that they must know how to read and be able to recite the blessing over the Torah.
• What if a Kohen is Unavailable?
  • If a Kohen is reciting the Shema (a central prayer) when it's time for his aliyah, he cannot be interrupted. In this case, an Israelite is called up in his place.
  • The glosses mention a specific scenario on fast days: if the Kohen is not fasting, an Israelite is called instead, and it's preferable for the Kohen to leave the synagogue. This shows how certain conditions can affect the application of the standard order.
  • If a Kohen enters the synagogue after an Israelite has already begun the blessing for the Torah reading, the Israelite does not stop. However, if only the opening "Bar'chu" (a call to prayer) has been said, it's not considered the beginning of the blessing, and the Israelite should wait until the Kohen and Levi have completed their aliyot, and then he reads.
  • If there is no Kohen in the synagogue, the Israelite reads in place of the Kohen, and a Levite is not called up after the Israelite. However, a Levite may be called for the first aliyah if there is no Kohen. The text notes that when calling up a non-Kohen in place of a Kohen, it is announced as "instead of a Kohen" to avoid confusion.

### Handling Substitutions and Multiple Kohanim/Levi'im

• Kohen Reading Twice: If a Kohen reads an aliyah, and then, mistakenly thinking there is no Levi present, begins the blessing for a second aliyah, he is not stopped.
• Kohen Reading for Levi: If there is no Levi, the same Kohen who read first blesses a second time and reads in place of the Levi. This is done to avoid calling up a different Kohen, which might lead people to believe the first Kohen's reading was invalid.
• Two Levi'im: Similarly, two Levi'im should not be called up one after the other to prevent the impression that one of them is invalid.
• Customs for Multiple Kohanim/Levi'im:
  • The custom is to call a Kohen after a Kohen if an Israelite has been called up between them. The prayer leader should announce when calling the second Kohen: "Even though he is a Kohen." The same applies to a Levi after a Levi.
  • The Rem"a (a later commentator) adds that this is permissible for the maftir aliyah (the final reading, often before the Haftarah). If they are called up without mentioning their name, there's no concern of people thinking they are invalid.
  • There's a differing opinion that Kohanim or Levi'im should not be called within the regular seven aliyot. Instead, they can be called after the seven have concluded. This latter opinion is the custom in some regions, but in cases of dire need, the first opinion can be relied upon.
• When Someone is Absent: If the prayer leader calls up a Kohen or Levi and they are not present, there's a custom not to call another by name, as this might imply the first person was invalid. Instead, another should go up on their own. The text clarifies that a prayer leader who is a Kohen may call up another Kohen.

### Special Cases and Cities

• City of Kohanim/Levi'im: In a city populated mainly by Kohanim or Levi'im, if there is one "Israelite" among them, that person should read first for the sake of peace. If there are not enough Israelites, or none at all, it is permitted to call a Kohen after a Kohen (or Levi after Levi) because there's no cause for suspicion of invalidity, as everyone knows the population consists of primarily Kohanim or Levi'im.
• Children Reading: The text defers to another section (Siman 282) for the rules regarding whether a child can read from the Torah in public.
• Kohen's Incapacity: Similarly, the rules for a Kohen who is blind or lacks expertise in reading are found in Siman 139.
• Prisoners: A significant and poignant rule is that people held in prison are not brought a Torah to read from, even on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. However, if a Torah is prepared for them a day or two prior, it is permitted. If the prisoner is an "important person," it is always permitted. This highlights a concern for the sanctity of the Torah and its public reading, while also acknowledging exceptions for individuals of stature.

How We Live This

Understanding these ancient laws and customs from the Shulchan Arukh opens a window into the enduring values that shape Jewish communal life. It's not just about following rules; it's about cultivating a specific atmosphere and a deep connection to our heritage.

### The Reverence for the Word

The entire process described, from the hushed recitation of "V'hu Rachum" to the meticulous presentation of the Torah scroll, is designed to instill a profound sense of reverence. When the scroll is unrolled and shown, and the congregation recites "V'zot Hatorah," it's a collective acknowledgment of the Divine origin and perfection of the Torah. This act isn't merely academic; it's an emotional and spiritual engagement. The commentaries that speak of "great light" being drawn down through looking at the letters hint at the spiritual impact intended.

How we live this today: We can bring this reverence into our own lives by approaching Jewish texts, whether it's a printed Chumash (Pentateuch) or an online resource, with a sense of respect. Understanding that these are the words that have guided our people for millennia can inspire a more thoughtful and intentional study. In synagogue, consciously observing these customs, even if not fully understanding every nuance, contributes to the sacred atmosphere.

### The Importance of Community and Inclusion

The emphasis on "mitzvah for all the men and women to see the writing" is a powerful statement of communal responsibility and inclusion. The Torah is not meant to be the exclusive possession of a few; it is a shared heritage. The varied customs and exceptions discussed—allowing extra aliyot for grooms or during brit milah, or the detailed rules about who reads when—all point to a desire to integrate significant life events and individuals into the communal fabric of Torah observance.

How we live this today: We can foster this sense of inclusion by actively participating in our community's Jewish life. This means being present for communal prayers, supporting lifecycle events, and encouraging others to learn and engage. Even if we don't fully understand the intricacies of aliyot or other rituals, our presence and willingness to learn signify our commitment to the collective. It's about recognizing that each person's participation, in their own way, contributes to the richness of Jewish tradition.

### The Value of Order and Tradition

The detailed ordering of who receives an aliyah – Kohen, then Levi, then Israelite – and the specific rules for substitutions highlight a deep respect for tradition and established order. This isn't about rigidness for its own sake, but about recognizing the wisdom embedded in practices developed over generations. The careful consideration given to potential misunderstandings (like why a Kohen might read twice, or how to announce a substitute) shows a concern for maintaining clarity and avoiding disruption to the spiritual flow.

How we live this today: We can embrace this value by appreciating the continuity of Jewish tradition. This involves learning about the history and evolution of our practices and understanding that what we do today is part of a long chain. When we participate in synagogue services, we are connecting with generations who performed these very rituals. This sense of belonging to a historical continuum can be incredibly grounding and inspiring.

### The Role of Education and Expertise

While the text prioritizes the status of a Kohen for the first aliyah, it crucially adds the caveat that they must know how to read. Similarly, the discussion about a Kohen lacking expertise defers to another section, implying that knowledge and ability are also essential components. This balances the importance of lineage with the necessity of competence. The inclusion of rules for when a Kohen or Levi is absent or unable to read demonstrates a pragmatic approach to ensuring the continuity of the service.

How we live this today: We can embody this by committing to our own Jewish education and encouraging others to do the same. This might mean attending classes, reading Jewish books, or engaging in meaningful conversations about Jewish texts and ideas. It also means recognizing and valuing the knowledge and expertise of those within our community who dedicate themselves to Jewish learning.

### The Balance of Practice and Principle

The glosses often highlight a distinction between an ideal rabbinic enactment and the actual practice. For example, the requirement to stand for "V'hu Rachum" versus the practice of saying it quietly. This demonstrates that Jewish law is not always a rigid, black-and-white system, but often involves nuanced interpretations and accommodations made over time to ensure that people can connect with the traditions in ways that are meaningful and feasible for them.

How we live this today: We can approach Jewish observance with understanding and compassion. Recognizing that different individuals and communities may have varying customs or levels of observance allows for greater empathy and connection. It encourages us to focus on the spirit of the mitzvot – the intention behind the actions – while respecting the diverse ways they are expressed.

One Thing to Remember

If there is one takeaway from this deep dive into the Shulchan Arukh, it's this: Jewish tradition meticulously orchestrates communal engagement with the Torah to foster reverence, unity, and a shared sense of Divine connection. Every detail, from the prayers said to the order of aliyot, is designed to elevate the reading of God's word into a profound, collective experience that binds us to the text, to each other, and to the Divine.

---

I hope this lesson has been enlightening and has provided a clear, empathetic introduction to these important aspects of Jewish practice. Please feel free to ask any questions you may have!