Tanakh Yomi · Memory & Meaning · On-Ramp

I Samuel 10:24-12:21

On-RampMemory & MeaningNovember 23, 2025

Here is a ritual guide for grief, remembrance, and legacy, drawing from I Samuel 10:24-12:21, crafted with a gentle, spacious, and ritual-wise tone, and offering hope without denial.

Hook

We gather today to mark a transition, a moment of profound change that resonates deeply with the experiences of loss and the ongoing process of remembrance. This passage from I Samuel speaks to the anointing of Saul, a moment of public elevation and expectation, yet it is also steeped in the quiet acknowledgement of what has been, and the inherent uncertainty of what is to come. It is a text that can speak to the shifting landscapes of our lives, particularly when we are navigating the aftermath of loss, where the familiar has been irrevocably altered, and we are called to step into a new reality, one that often feels both chosen and imposed upon us. This is a space for those who are ready to explore the echoes of the past within the unfolding present, to honor the way life transforms, and to find meaning in the continuity of our connections.

Text Snapshot

Samuel took a flask of oil and poured some on Saul’s head and kissed him, and said, “God herewith anoints you ruler over this people—God’s own. … When you leave me today, you will meet two men near the tomb of Rachel… And once these signs have happened to you, act when the occasion arises, for God is with you. … As [Saul] turned around to leave Samuel, God gave him another heart; and all those signs were fulfilled that same day. … And Samuel said to the people, “Do you see the one whom God has chosen? There is none like him among all the people.” And all the people acclaimed him, shouting, “Long live the king!”

Kavvanah

Holding the Weight of Transition

Our intention today is to hold, with gentleness and spaciousness, the multifaceted experience of transition, particularly as it arises in the context of grief and remembrance. This passage invites us to consider moments of profound change, both chosen and unexpected, and how we navigate the space between what was and what is becoming. We approach this ritual with an open heart, recognizing that grief is not a linear path, and that remembrance is an active, evolving practice. We aim to cultivate a sense of presence, acknowledging the weight of our experiences, the stories that shape us, and the quiet strength that emerges when we allow ourselves to be present with what is.

Acknowledging Unseen Forces and Chosen Paths

The anointing of Saul is a moment of divine selection, yet it is also a moment where Saul is guided by signs and where his heart is changed by God. This speaks to the interplay between external forces and our internal responses. As we engage with this text, we can hold the intention of acknowledging the unseen currents that shape our lives, the moments of grace, the shifts in perspective that can feel as though our hearts are being given anew. Simultaneously, we can honor the agency we possess, the choices we make, and the ways we actively engage with the unfolding of our lives, even in the wake of loss.

Finding Strength in the Unfolding Narrative

This passage culminates in Samuel’s powerful address to the people, reminding them of God’s past faithfulness and the consequences of forgetting. It is a moment of profound reckoning, but also of enduring hope. Our intention is to draw strength from this unfolding narrative, to see ourselves not as static figures defined solely by loss, but as participants in a continuous story. We seek to understand how the past informs the present, how lessons learned can guide our future, and how, even when we feel we have strayed, the possibility of return and renewed commitment remains. This ritual is an invitation to find resilience in the face of hardship and to believe in the possibility of continued growth and meaning.

Practice

The Unfolding Landscape: A Map of Your Inner World

This micro-practice invites you to engage with the text through a gentle, internal mapping process, honoring the idea that our inner landscapes, like the external ones described in the text, can shift and change. It is a practice designed to be accessible and adaptable to your current emotional state, offering a tangible way to connect with the themes of transition, remembrance, and the unfolding of your life's journey.

Option 1: The Anointed Path (For those feeling a sense of new beginnings or a subtle shift)

  1. Gather Your Materials: Find a piece of paper (any kind will do), a pen or pencil, and a quiet space where you can be undisturbed for about five minutes.
  2. The Anointing Oil: Imagine Samuel pouring oil on Saul’s head. This oil is a symbol of anointing, of being set apart, of a new role or a shift in being. What does this oil represent for you today? Is it a balm of comfort, a spark of renewed purpose, a gentle acknowledgement of a change? Write down a few words or a short phrase that captures this essence on your paper.
  3. The Signs and the Journey: The text describes Saul encountering specific signs on his journey after his anointing. Think about your own journey, particularly in relation to your grief or remembrance. What are the "signs" that have appeared for you? These could be moments of unexpected comfort, a sudden memory, a realization, a feeling of connection, or even a challenging experience that led to a new understanding.
  4. Mapping the Signs: On your paper, create a simple visual map. You can start by drawing a central point representing your current self or a significant memory. Then, draw lines branching out from this point, representing the "signs" you've encountered. Next to each line, briefly jot down what the sign was or what it felt like. Don't overthink this; let it be spontaneous.
  5. The Changed Heart: The text says, "God gave him another heart." This doesn't mean the old heart was discarded, but rather that it was transformed, capable of holding new experiences and responsibilities. Reflect on how your own heart has been changed by your experiences, by your grief, by your acts of remembrance. You can draw a subtle change in the central point of your map, or add a small symbol that represents this new capacity.
  6. The "Act When the Occasion Arises": This phrase suggests a readiness to respond. Consider one small way you can "act" in accordance with this transformed heart or the insights gained from your mapped signs. It might be a simple act of self-care, reaching out to someone, or engaging in a meaningful activity. Write this down at the bottom of your map.

Option 2: The Hidden Donkey (For those feeling a sense of searching or quiet disorientation)

  1. Gather Your Materials: Find a piece of paper (any kind will do), a pen or pencil, and a quiet space where you can be undisturbed for about five minutes.
  2. The Lost Donkeys: Saul’s initial journey was to find lost donkeys. This can represent moments when we feel we are searching for something that is lost, something familiar that has gone missing in our lives, perhaps a sense of peace, clarity, or connection. On your paper, draw a simple outline of a donkey, or write the word "Donkeys." This is a symbol of what feels elusive.
  3. The Unexpected Encounter: Saul was on his way to find something lost, but he encountered Samuel and the prophecy of his anointing. This is often how life unfolds: when we are searching for one thing, we find something else, something unexpected. Think about a time when, in your own search for solace or understanding after a loss, you stumbled upon something entirely different – a new perspective, an unexpected kindness, a forgotten strength.
  4. The "Found" and the "Worry": The text mentions the donkeys being found, but also Saul’s father worrying about him. This duality is common in grief. We may find moments of peace or clarity (the found donkeys), but the underlying worry or concern for ourselves and our loved ones remains. On your paper, you can draw a small circle around your "Donkeys" to signify they have been "found" in some way. Then, draw a faint cloud or a question mark next to it to represent the lingering worry or the ongoing nature of the search.
  5. The Whispers of Change: Saul’s uncle asks about Samuel’s words, and Saul downplays them. This can represent the moments when we are hesitant to share the full depth of our inner experiences, perhaps because they are too new, too fragile, or too difficult to articulate. Consider what "whispers" of change or insight you might be holding onto, things you haven't fully shared or acknowledged. You can write these as small, almost illegible words around the edges of your paper.
  6. The "Hidden" Within the Baggage: When Saul is sought for kingship, he is found hiding among the baggage. This can symbolize the times when we feel we are hiding, perhaps feeling unworthy or overwhelmed by the attention or the responsibility that life unexpectedly places upon us. You can draw a small, shadowy figure within the "baggage" area of your paper. This figure represents the part of you that is observing, perhaps a little apprehensive, but present.

Option 3: The People's Voice (For those reflecting on collective experience or societal impact)

  1. Gather Your Materials: Find a piece of paper (any kind will do), a pen or pencil, and a quiet space where you can be undisturbed for about five minutes.
  2. The Uproar and the Acclamation: The text describes the people's reaction to Saul's anointing: "And all the people acclaimed him, shouting, 'Long live the king!'" Later, after the Ammonite crisis, they also say, "Who was it said, ‘Shall Saul be king over us?’ Hand over those involved—and we will put them to death!" On your paper, draw a large circle in the center. This represents the collective voice.
  3. Echoes of the Past: Samuel reminds the people of God's past actions and their repeated tendency to forget and turn away. Think about the collective narratives that have shaped your community, your family, or society at large, especially in relation to loss or significant historical events. What are the recurring themes or "songs" that are sung? You can write these themes as short phrases around the outer edge of your circle.
  4. The "Rejection" and the "Yearning": The people rejected God as their ruler and asked for a king. This can mirror moments when we, or our communities, feel a sense of loss or a yearning for something different, perhaps a strong leader or a clear path, even when guidance has already been provided. In the space between your themes and the central circle, draw symbols representing this tension – perhaps a broken line and a hopeful upward curve.
  5. The "Testify Against Me": Samuel's honest accounting of his leadership, asking the people to testify against him, is a powerful act of integrity. Consider a moment when you, or a collective you are part of, have been called to account. How was this received? You can draw small tally marks within the central circle to represent the "testimonies" – whether they were positive, negative, or mixed.
  6. The "Marvelous Thing": Samuel predicts a "marvelous thing" from God – thunder and rain during the wheat harvest, a sign that the people's request for a king was misguided. This is a reminder that even in moments of perceived wrongdoing or crisis, there can be a revelation, a moment of profound understanding that emerges. You can draw a small cloud with lightning bolts and rain within the central circle, signifying this divine intervention and the subsequent awe.

Community

Sharing the Echoes of Our Journeys

One of the most profound ways to honor our journeys of grief and remembrance is to connect with others who understand the landscape of transition. This passage, while focusing on individual anointing and public pronouncements, also highlights the collective experience of the people of Israel.

Option 1: The Shared Song of "Long Live"

Consider reaching out to a trusted friend, family member, or a member of a support group. Share with them one of the "signs" you identified in your practice, or simply the feeling of transition you are holding. You can frame it by saying, "Today, I've been reflecting on moments of change and how we navigate them. I was reminded of the people shouting 'Long live the king!' – a moment of collective affirmation. Is there a moment of collective affirmation or a shared song that has brought you comfort or a sense of continuity in your own journey?"

Option 2: The Quiet Witness of the Elders

The elders of Jabesh-Gilead request a seven-day respite, a communal act of seeking support and considering their options. This can be a powerful metaphor for how we can seek support in our own moments of crisis or transition. Identify one person in your life who has been a "witness" to your journey, someone who has offered quiet support or a listening ear. You might send them a simple message, like: "I've been thinking about the wisdom of seeking time and support when facing difficult decisions, like the elders of Jabesh-Gilead. Your presence has been such a quiet strength for me. Thank you."

Option 3: The Proverbial Wisdom of the People

The proverb, "Is Saul too among the prophets?" arose from a moment of collective surprise and questioning. This reminds us that our experiences, even when unique, can resonate with others in unexpected ways. Consider sharing a small, anonymized observation from your practice (e.g., "I noticed how often we search for one thing and find another") with a wider community forum, a spiritual group, or even a social media platform dedicated to thoughtful reflection. You can pose it as a question: "In our journeys, have you found that when you're searching for something lost, you often stumble upon something entirely unexpected?" This invites others to share their own proverbial wisdom.

Takeaway

As we conclude this ritual, we carry with us the understanding that transition is an inherent part of life, marked by both profound shifts and the quiet continuity of our being. The story of Saul’s anointing, with its signs, its inner transformation, and its public reception, offers a rich tapestry for reflecting on our own journeys of remembrance and legacy. May we approach these transitions with the gentleness of Samuel’s oil, the courage to embrace the unexpected signs that appear, and the enduring hope that, like Saul, we too can find strength and purpose in the unfolding of our lives, even as we honor all that has come before.