I Samuel 26:25-28:23

This is a substantial request, and I'm excited to dive into this rich text with you! Let's embark on this journey of Jewish parenting through the lens of I Samuel 26-28.

Insight

The narrative of David and Saul, particularly in the passages before us, offers a profound yet accessible exploration of how we navigate power, morality, and the often-frustrating realities of raising children. We see David, a man on the run, consistently choosing restraint and moral integrity even when presented with the ultimate opportunity to eliminate his adversary. He has Saul at his mercy, asleep and vulnerable, yet he refuses to strike him down, citing the sanctity of God's anointed. This is not just a historical account; it's a blueprint for how we, as parents, can model ethical decision-making in the face of our children's challenging behaviors or our own overwhelming frustrations. Our children, like Saul, can sometimes feel like adversaries in their actions, pushing boundaries, testing limits, and seemingly acting against our best interests. In these moments, it's easy to feel justified in lashing out, in imposing harsh punishments, or in succumbing to anger. David's example, however, implores us to pause, to consider the "higher ground," and to recognize that our actions have long-term consequences, not just for our children but for our own spiritual and moral well-being.

This section of I Samuel highlights a critical parenting challenge: how to respond to perceived defiance or wrongdoing without resorting to destructive tactics. David’s deliberate choice not to harm Saul, even when physically able to do so, underscores the importance of restraint and the understanding that true power lies not in dominance but in self-control and adherence to a moral compass. For parents, this translates into how we handle tantrums, sibling squabbles, or outright defiance. Do we react with immediate, forceful retribution, or do we pause, assess the situation, and choose a response that aligns with our values and aims for long-term growth rather than short-term compliance? The text suggests that our children are not merely objects to be controlled but individuals with souls, and our interactions with them should reflect a deep respect for their inherent worth, even when their behavior is difficult. David’s actions are a testament to the idea that sometimes, the most powerful response is a quiet, principled refusal to engage in harmful behavior. This requires a level of emotional maturity and foresight that can be incredibly challenging to cultivate, especially when we are tired, stressed, and feeling undermined by our children's actions. It’s about understanding that our children are also on a journey, a journey of learning and growth, and our role is to guide them with wisdom and compassion, even when they stumble.

Furthermore, the story of Saul seeking out the witch of Endor, driven by fear and desperation when God doesn't answer him, offers a stark warning about the consequences of straying from our ethical path and the dangers of seeking answers from misguided sources. For parents, this means recognizing when we are in a place of spiritual or emotional depletion, and knowing where to turn for genuine support and guidance. Are we seeking advice from sources that encourage reactive, punitive parenting, or are we connecting with mentors, communities, or spiritual practices that reinforce our values of love, patience, and understanding? When we feel lost or overwhelmed, it's tempting to grasp at any solution, but the text urges us to be discerning. The true "answer" for Saul would have been to remain faithful and to trust in God's plan, even when it was unclear, rather than resorting to forbidden practices. Similarly, for parents, when we feel like God has "turned away" from us in our parenting struggles, it’s crucial to remember our core values and to seek out wisdom that aligns with them, rather than falling into patterns of behavior that we later regret. This can mean seeking out parenting books that promote positive discipline, connecting with other parents who share our values, or engaging in practices that strengthen our own spiritual core, allowing us to approach parenting from a place of groundedness and faith.

The narrative also implicitly teaches us about the long-term consequences of our actions. David’s restraint, though it may have prolonged his time on the run, ultimately solidified his character and paved the way for his eventual kingship. Saul's desperation, on the other hand, led him to actions that further alienated him from God and ultimately sealed his fate. In our parenting, the choices we make today – the ways we discipline, the words we use, the values we impart – will shape our children’s futures. Are we building a foundation of trust, resilience, and ethical understanding, or are we inadvertently creating a legacy of fear, resentment, or moral compromise? This requires us to think beyond the immediate situation and to consider the ripple effects of our parenting decisions. It’s about understanding that every interaction, every decision, is an investment in our child's future character and well-being. The challenge, of course, is that we don't always see the immediate results, and sometimes it feels like our efforts are in vain. But just as David’s seemingly small acts of integrity eventually led to his triumph, our consistent, values-driven parenting, even in the face of difficulty, has the power to shape our children in profound ways. This also speaks to the importance of modeling these values ourselves. Our children are constantly observing us, and they learn as much from what we do as they do from what we say. If we are quick to anger, if we compromise our values for convenience, or if we seek easy answers to complex problems, they will absorb these lessons. David’s ability to resist temptation and to act with integrity in a moment of extreme pressure is a powerful testament to the kind of character we aspire to build in ourselves and to foster in our children.

The text also presents a subtle but powerful insight into the concept of "God's anointed." For David, this meant respecting Saul's position, even when Saul was acting unjustly. This concept can be translated into parenting as respecting the inherent dignity and, in a sense, the "anointed" status of our children. Each child is a precious soul, a unique creation, and deserving of our respect, even when they are making poor choices. This doesn't mean excusing bad behavior, but it does mean approaching the child with an understanding that they are more than their actions. It means recognizing their potential for good and their capacity for growth. When we see our children through this lens, we are less likely to engage in shaming or demeaning tactics, and more likely to approach them with the intention of guiding them towards their best selves. The very act of calling Saul "my lord king" and referring to himself as Saul's "servant" demonstrates David's deep respect for the established order and for Saul's personhood, even in the midst of extreme personal danger. This is a powerful lesson for parents who may feel that their authority is constantly being challenged. By modeling respect, even when it's difficult, we can foster a more respectful dynamic in our own homes. It's about seeing our children not as adversaries to be conquered, but as individuals with whom we are on a shared journey, and whose inherent worth we must always acknowledge. This, in turn, helps them develop their own sense of self-worth and their own capacity for empathy and respect towards others.

Finally, the narrative encourages us to embrace the "good-enough" parenting approach. David doesn't achieve his kingship in a single, dramatic act of vengeance or conquest. His journey is marked by periods of hiding, of strategic maneuvering, and of moments of immense moral struggle. Similarly, our parenting journeys are rarely linear or perfect. There will be days when we feel like we've failed, when our children are pushing our buttons, and when we barely manage to keep our heads above water. The key is to keep showing up, to keep trying, and to learn from our mistakes. David's refusal to kill Saul, even when offered the perfect opportunity, is a micro-win of immense proportions. It demonstrates a commitment to a higher principle that transcends immediate gratification or revenge. For us, micro-wins can be as simple as choosing a calm response instead of an angry outburst, taking a deep breath before reacting, or finding a moment of connection with our child amidst the chaos. These small, consistent efforts, like David’s restraint, build a foundation of strong character and enduring relationships. The text reminds us that perfection is not the goal; rather, it is persistent effort, guided by integrity and love, that truly matters.

Text Snapshot

David and Abishai approached the troops by night, and found Saul fast asleep inside the barricade, his spear stuck in the ground at his head, and Abner and the troops sleeping around him. And Abishai said to David, “God has delivered your enemy into your hands today. Let me pin him to the ground with a single thrust of the spear. I will not have to strike him twice.” But David said to Abishai, “Don’t do him violence! No one can lay hands on GOD’s anointed with impunity.” (I Samuel 26:7-9)

When Saul saw the Philistine force, his heart trembled with fear. And Saul inquired of GOD, but GOD did not answer him, either by dreams or by Urim or by prophets. Then Saul said to his courtiers, “Find me a woman who consults ghosts, so that I can go to her and inquire through her.” (I Samuel 28:5-7)

Activity

The "What If?" Scenario Game (Designed for ages 5-12, adaptable for teens)

This activity encourages children to think about ethical dilemmas and to consider different courses of action, mirroring David’s choices.

For Younger Children (Ages 5-8):

• Materials: Paper, crayons, or markers.
• Setup: Sit down with your child and explain that you're going to play a "What If?" game.
• Activity: Present simple scenarios that involve choices with potential consequences.
  • "What if your friend takes your toy without asking? What could you do?" (Options: Get angry and grab it back, tell them it's not okay, ask them to share, tell a grown-up).
  • "What if you see someone drop their ice cream? What could you do?" (Options: Laugh, help them clean it up, offer to share yours if you have one, ignore it).
  • "What if you accidentally break something? What could you do?" (Options: Hide it, tell the truth, try to fix it).
• Discussion: After they suggest an action, ask "Why would you do that?" and "What might happen if you did that?" Gently guide them towards choices that demonstrate kindness, honesty, and responsibility. For example, if they choose to get angry, you can say, "Getting angry might feel good for a moment, but what happens next? What if you tried asking nicely first?"
• Connect to Text: Briefly mention David's situation: "David had a chance to hurt Saul, but he chose not to because it wasn't the right thing to do. Even though it was hard, he chose to be kind and respectful."

For Older Children (Ages 9-12):

• Materials: Paper, pens, or a whiteboard.
• Setup: Explain that you're going to explore some tricky situations, like the ones David faced.
• Activity: Present more complex scenarios.
  • "Imagine you're playing a game, and your friend is losing badly. They start blaming you for cheating, even though you didn't. What could you do?" (Options: Get defensive, calmly explain you didn't cheat, walk away, try to cheer them up).
  • "You see your classmate struggling with their homework, and you know the answer. The teacher isn't around. What could you do?" (Options: Give them the answer directly, help them understand how to find the answer, ignore it).
  • "Your parent asks you to do a chore, but you're really tired and want to relax. What are your options?" (Options: Refuse outright, complain but do it, negotiate a time, do half of it now and half later).
• Discussion: For each scenario, have them brainstorm at least three possible responses. Then, discuss the pros and cons of each response. Ask questions like:
  • "What is the easiest thing to do? What is the right thing to do?"
  • "How might each choice make the other person feel?"
  • "What are the long-term consequences of each choice?"
• Connect to Text: "Remember how David had Saul in his power? He could have easily hurt him. But he chose to be principled. He knew that even when it's hard, doing the right thing is important. What in these scenarios feels like the 'right thing to do'?"

For Teenagers (Adaptation):

• Materials: Journal or notebook, or a shared document.
• Setup: Frame this as a character-building exercise. Discuss the pressures and temptations teenagers face.
• Activity: Present scenarios that mirror the complexities of I Samuel 26-28.
  • "You discover a close friend is involved in something risky or unethical. They ask you to keep it a secret. What are your options, and what are the implications of each?" (Options: Confront them, tell a trusted adult, distance yourself, go along with it).
  • "You're facing a significant decision about your future (college, career, etc.), and you're getting conflicting advice from different people you respect. How do you discern the right path? What if you feel lost or like you don't have clear guidance?" (This can connect to Saul's desperation).
  • "You've been wronged by someone in a position of authority (teacher, coach, employer). You have an opportunity to expose them, but it could have significant repercussions for you. What do you do?"
• Discussion: Encourage them to explore the nuances of each decision. Discuss the difference between immediate relief and long-term integrity. Explore the concept of "God's anointed" as respecting the inherent dignity of individuals, even when they err. Discuss the dangers of seeking easy answers or succumbing to fear and desperation, as Saul did.
• Connect to Text: "David's choice not to harm Saul was about more than just survival; it was about maintaining his own integrity and trusting in a higher power. When you face difficult choices, where do you find your compass? What does it mean to you to be 'anointed' or to act with integrity?"

Variations for All Ages:

• Role-Playing: Act out the scenarios. This can be especially engaging for younger children.
• Story Writing: Have older children write short stories based on similar dilemmas.
• Art Projects: Younger children can draw their responses to the "What If?" scenarios.

Time Commitment: 10 minutes for younger children, 15-20 minutes for older children and teens.

Script

(Scenario: Your child has done something wrong, and you're struggling to keep your cool. You want to respond with a lesson, not just anger.)

For Younger Children (Ages 4-7):

Parent: "Hey, sweetie. I see that [action child did]. I know you might have been feeling [possible emotion child felt], but [action] wasn't a good choice. It hurt [person/thing] and it's not okay. Right now, my tummy feels a little upset because I'm frustrated. But I want to help you learn from this. Let's take a deep breath together. (Model deep breath). What do you think you could do differently next time?"

For Elementary Schoolers (Ages 8-11):

Parent: "Okay, so [child's name], we need to talk about what happened with [situation]. I'm feeling [your emotion, e.g., disappointed, concerned] because [explain the impact of their action]. I understand you might have been [possible reason for their action], but the way you handled it wasn't in line with our family values. Remember how David chose not to hurt Saul even when he had the chance? That was about choosing the right path even when it was hard. What do you think is the right path for you in this situation? What can we learn from this so it doesn't happen again?"

For Teenagers (Ages 12+):

Parent: "Can we talk for a few minutes about [situation]? I'm not here to yell, but I need you to understand that [their action] has consequences, and frankly, it concerns me. I'm feeling [your emotion, e.g., worried, confused] because [explain your concern]. From the story of David and Saul, we see that even when faced with immense pressure, David held onto his integrity. He refused to take the easy, vengeful route. What does that story say to you about how you're navigating [their specific challenge]? What's your plan to move forward from this, and how can I support you in making better choices?"

---

(Scenario: Your child asks an uncomfortable question about something they overheard or observed, perhaps something morally ambiguous or scary.)

For Younger Children (Ages 4-7):

Child: "Mommy, why did that man yell at the other man like that?" or "Is that person bad?"

Parent: (Gently) "That was a situation where someone was feeling very upset, and they didn't use their words in a kind way. It's important for us to use our words to talk about our feelings, even when we're angry or sad. Sometimes people make mistakes or don't know how to handle their feelings. We can try to be understanding, but we also know that it's not okay to be mean or hurtful. Let's talk about how we can use our words when we feel upset."

For Elementary Schoolers (Ages 8-11):

Child: "Why did Saul want to hurt David so much? He seemed really mean."

Parent: "That's a really good question. Saul was going through a lot. He was afraid of David, and he felt threatened. Sometimes when people are scared or feel like they're losing control, they do things that aren't kind or fair. It reminds me a little of when Saul was so scared about the Philistines that he even went to a forbidden place to try and get answers. It's a reminder that being afraid can make us do things we shouldn't. We need to learn to handle our fears in healthy ways, like talking to someone we trust or finding ways to calm ourselves down."

For Teenagers (Ages 12+):

Child: "This story is confusing. David had a chance to kill Saul, but he didn't. But then he went and raided villages and killed everyone? That doesn't make sense."

Parent: "That's a really insightful observation, and you've hit on a complex part of these ancient texts and even human nature. You're right, David’s actions are not always easy to reconcile. On one hand, he demonstrated incredible restraint and moral courage in not laying a hand on Saul, respecting his anointing. On the other hand, his raiding practices in Philistine territory, while possibly a strategic move for survival and to deceive Achish, involved significant violence. These texts often present us with flawed heroes, and they force us to grapple with difficult questions about power, survival, and morality. It's okay to find it confusing. What these passages ask us to consider is that even 'good' people make difficult choices, and sometimes those choices have unintended or even negative consequences. The challenge for us, as parents and as people, is to strive for David's level of integrity when faced with direct temptation, while also being mindful of the broader impact of our actions and seeking wisdom to navigate those complexities. What does that tension between his restraint with Saul and his actions against the Amalekites make you think about?"

---

(Scenario: Your child is struggling with a moral dilemma and you want to help them find their own solution, inspired by David's wisdom.)

For Younger Children (Ages 4-7):

Child: "My friend took my crayon and I want it back NOW!"

Parent: "Oh no, that's frustrating! It feels yucky when someone takes our things, doesn't it? What do you think David would do if someone took something from him when he was trying to be good? (Pause for thought). David chose to take Saul's spear and water jar, but he didn't hurt him. He found a way to show Saul what happened without being mean. What's a way you could show your friend that you want your crayon back without being mean?"

For Elementary Schoolers (Ages 8-11):

Child: "I know Jenny cheated on the test, but she’s my friend. Should I tell the teacher?"

Parent: "That's a tough spot to be in. It's like when David had to decide what to do about Saul. He could have done something that seemed easy or even justified in the moment, but he chose a different path based on his principles. What do you think David's principles were in that situation? (Guide them towards integrity, respect for God's anointed). Now, thinking about those principles, what feels like the most honest and fair way to handle this situation with Jenny and the teacher? What are the potential outcomes of telling, and what are the potential outcomes of not telling? What feels like the 'good-enough' way to be a good friend and also be honest?"

For Teenagers (Ages 12+):

Child: "I've been asked to lie for my friend about where they were last night. I don't want to, but they said they'll be in huge trouble."

Parent: "This is a real test of character, isn't it? It echoes some of the difficult choices David faced. He had to navigate loyalty, truth, and his own safety. What did you learn from David's decision not to harm Saul, even when he had the perfect opportunity? What was that about for him? (Guide them towards the sanctity of life, integrity, and trust in divine justice). Now, apply that to your situation. What are the risks and rewards of lying? What are the risks and rewards of telling the truth? And what does it mean for your own character to be involved in a lie, even for a friend? What kind of 'anointed' are you in this situation – what are you called to uphold?"

Habit

The "Pause and Assess" Micro-Habit

This week, let's cultivate the habit of pausing before reacting, especially in moments of frustration or conflict with our children. This mirrors David's deliberate choice to assess the situation and his options before acting.

Micro-Habit: The 5-Second Breath Before Responding.

How to do it:

1. Identify the Trigger: Notice when your child does something that makes you feel annoyed, frustrated, or angry. It could be a spilled drink, a whiny complaint, a defiance of a simple instruction.
2. The Pause: Before you speak or act, take a deliberate, conscious breath. Count to five in your head. This is not about holding your breath; it's about creating a tiny, mental space between the stimulus and your response.
3. The Quick Assess: In those five seconds, ask yourself:
   • "What is the core issue here?" (Is it the spilled milk, or the underlying tiredness/hunger/boredom?)
   • "What is my goal in responding?" (To punish, to teach, to connect, to gain compliance?)
   • "Is my immediate, angry reaction serving my goal?"
4. Respond (or Not): After the 5-second pause, you can then choose your response. It might be a calmer verbal correction, a request for them to help clean up, or even a moment to acknowledge your own feelings and then proceed.

Why it's a Micro-Win: This habit is incredibly time-boxed (literally 5 seconds!) and requires no special equipment or preparation. It's about building a tiny muscle of self-regulation. Even if you don't get it perfect every time, the attempt to pause is a win. It interrupts the automatic, reactive cycle that often leads to parental guilt and strained relationships. It’s about choosing intention over impulse.

For the Week: Don't aim for perfection. Aim for awareness. If you forget to pause, just acknowledge it and try again the next time. Celebrate the moments you do remember to take that breath. This is about progress, not perfection.

Takeaway

The stories of David and Saul in I Samuel 26-28 offer us a profound, yet practical, lens through which to view our parenting. David’s deliberate restraint in the face of ultimate provocation teaches us the power of moral integrity and self-control, urging us to choose thoughtful responses over reactive outbursts. Saul's desperate turn to forbidden practices, when faced with fear and divine silence, serves as a potent reminder to seek wisdom from sources aligned with our values and to trust in a higher plan, even when it's unclear. By embracing the "Pause and Assess" micro-habit, we can cultivate the space needed to model these principles for our children. Remember, the goal isn't perfection, but consistent, "good-enough" tries, celebrated with kindness and a deep understanding that our children, like David, are on a journey of becoming, and our steady, principled guidance is their greatest gift.