Tanakh Yomi · Judaism 101: The Foundations · On-Ramp

I Samuel 9:2-10:23

On-RampJudaism 101: The FoundationsNovember 21, 2025

Judaism 101: The Foundations

The Big Question

Have you ever felt like you were just going through the motions, searching for something more, something meaningful? Perhaps you've experienced a situation where you were looking for something lost, only to find something entirely unexpected and profound. In the tapestry of Jewish history and tradition, such moments are not mere coincidences; they are often divine appointments, turning points that shape destinies and reveal deeper truths. Our journey today delves into one such pivotal moment, the dramatic, and perhaps even humorous, encounter that leads to the anointing of Israel's first king.

This passage from the book of I Samuel is more than just a historical narrative; it's a story that resonates with universal human experiences: the search for lost things, the feeling of inadequacy, the unexpected call to leadership, and the unfolding of a divine plan. It asks us to consider: What happens when the ordinary search for lost donkeys leads to an extraordinary encounter with destiny? How does an unassuming young man, perhaps even unaware of his own potential, become the chosen leader of an entire nation? And what does this reveal about the nature of God's involvement in the world, and our own potential to be part of something greater than ourselves?

This story invites us to ponder the ways in which we, too, might be called to unexpected paths, and how even in our moments of searching for the mundane, we might be on the cusp of discovering something divinely ordained. It challenges us to look beyond the surface of events and to consider the deeper currents of meaning and purpose that may be at play in our lives.

One Core Concept

The core concept we will explore is Divine Providence and the Unfolding of Destiny. This refers to the belief that God actively oversees and guides the course of history and individual lives, often in ways that are not immediately apparent. It suggests that seemingly random events can be part of a larger, purposeful plan, and that individuals are called to play a role in that unfolding destiny.

Breaking It Down

This narrative from I Samuel, chapters 9 and 10, is a foundational story in Jewish history, marking a significant transition in the governance of the Israelites. It’s the account of how Saul, a seemingly ordinary young man, is unexpectedly chosen and anointed as Israel's first king. Let's break down this rich passage into its key components.

The Humble Beginning: Lost Donkeys and a Humble Search

Our story begins with a rather relatable domestic crisis: Saul's father, Kish, has lost his donkeys. This isn't a grand quest for national salvation; it's a practical problem that requires a practical solution. Saul, described as an "excellent young man," handsome, and notably taller than anyone else, is tasked with finding them. This physical stature, as noted by commentaries like Malbim and Metzudat David, is not just a physical attribute but also hints at a potential leadership quality, setting him apart even before his divine calling. Radak and Metzudat Zion emphasize his handsome appearance and height, suggesting he was already visually distinguished. Alshich further elaborates that this imposing presence was also intended to instill respect, fitting for a future king.

Saul and his servant embark on a fruitless search, traversing various regions of Benjamin. As their supplies dwindle and their hope wanes, Saul expresses a natural desire to turn back, fearing his father's concern for them will overshadow the lost donkeys. This moment highlights Saul's inherent humility and his concern for his family's well-being.

The Encounter with the Seer: A Divine Hint

It is the servant who introduces the idea of seeking out a "seer," a prophet of God. This figure, as explained in the text, was formerly known as a seer because people would go to them to inquire of God. This is a crucial point: even in everyday matters, the Israelites understood that seeking divine guidance was a legitimate recourse. The servant’s suggestion to consult the seer demonstrates a societal understanding of the connection between the mundane and the divine. The text notes that the seer is "highly esteemed" and that "everything that he says comes true," underscoring the seer's authority and spiritual insight.

Saul, initially practical and concerned about what they could offer as a gift – the servant's meager quarter-shekel of silver becomes the humble offering – agrees to the plan. Their journey to the seer's town leads to another significant detail: they meet young women drawing water, a common scene in ancient life. Their inquiries about the seer, and the women's hurried directions ("Hurry, for he has just come to the town... because the people have a sacrifice at the shrine today!"), build anticipation. The text emphasizes that people would not eat until the seer blessed the sacrifice, further illustrating the seer's central role in communal life and religious observance.

The Revelation: God's Plan Unveiled

The dramatic turning point occurs as Saul and his servant enter the town. Samuel, the seer, is on his way to the shrine, and crucially, God had revealed to Samuel the day before that He would send a man from Benjamin to be anointed ruler. This foreknowledge is paramount. It’s not a chance encounter; it’s a divinely orchestrated meeting. God explicitly tells Samuel, "This is the man that I told you would govern My people."

When Saul approaches Samuel, asking for the seer’s house, Samuel’s direct response, "I am the seer," is both startling and definitive. He then invites Saul to eat with him, assuring him about the found donkeys and then dropping a bombshell: "And for whom is all Israel yearning, if not for you and all your ancestral house?" Saul's reaction is one of profound disbelief and humility. He, a member of the smallest tribe and the least significant clan of Benjamin, can't fathom why such pronouncements would be made about him. This contrast between God’s divine knowledge and Saul’s self-perception is a central theme.

The Anointing and the Signs: A Transformation Begins

The meal with Samuel is significant. Saul is given a place of honor, a testament to the seer's recognition of his destiny, even if Saul himself doesn't fully grasp it. The next morning, as they prepare to depart, Samuel takes Saul aside. In a private moment, Samuel anoints Saul with oil, a symbolic act of consecration and divine selection, declaring, "God herewith anoints you ruler over this people."

What follows is a series of prophetic signs that Samuel provides to Saul. These signs are not random; they are designed to confirm God's word and to prepare Saul for his new role. They include meeting men who confirm the donkeys are found and his father's concern, encountering pilgrims who offer him bread, and, most dramatically, joining a group of prophets speaking in ecstasy. It is during this encounter with the prophets that the "spirit of God will grip you, and you will speak in ecstasy along with them; you will become a different person." This is the moment of transformation, where Saul, the humble donkey-finder, begins to embody the person God has chosen. The text explicitly states, "God gave him another heart," signifying a profound internal shift.

The Aftermath: The People's Reaction and the Seeds of Doubt

The fulfillment of these signs that same day, including Saul speaking in ecstasy among the prophets, causes astonishment among those who knew him. The proverb, "Is Saul too among the prophets?" captures the collective surprise and the radical change in his demeanor.

However, the narrative doesn't end with universal acceptance. When Saul returns home, not everyone is convinced. Some "scoundrels" scorn him, asking, "How can this fellow save us?" and bringing him no gift. This foreshadows the challenges and opposition Saul will face as king. Despite this, Saul, in his newfound state, "pretended not to mind," demonstrating a level of maturity and restraint.

The chapter culminates with Samuel gathering the people at Mizpah. He reminds them of God's past deliverances and their current rejection of God by demanding a king. Through a process of divine selection involving tribes and clans, Saul is identified. His initial hiding among the baggage, a sign of his lingering humility or perhaps apprehension, is revealed by God. When brought forth, he stands, once again, a head taller than all the people, physically embodying the leadership he has been chosen for. Samuel declares, "There is none like him among all the people," and the people acclaim him, "Long live the king!"

This passage intricately weaves together themes of humility, divine calling, personal transformation, and the complexities of leadership. It shows that God's choices are often unexpected, and that the journey to leadership can begin with the most ordinary of circumstances.

How We Live This

This story, while ancient, offers profound lessons for how we approach our own lives and our relationship with the Divine.

Embracing the Unexpected Callings

The most striking aspect of Saul's story is that his journey to kingship begins with a mundane errand. This teaches us that opportunities for growth, service, and even leadership can arise from unexpected places and in seemingly trivial situations. We shouldn't dismiss our daily tasks or routines as unimportant. Instead, we can approach them with a mindset of attentiveness, openness to possibility, and a willingness to be present. Perhaps a conversation with a neighbor, a challenging project at work, or a volunteer opportunity could be the start of a new path, a way for us to be God's instrument.

The Importance of Humility and Self-Awareness

Saul's initial disbelief and his self-description as being from the "smallest of the tribes" and the "least of all the clans" highlight the crucial virtue of humility. True leadership, and indeed spiritual growth, often begins with an honest assessment of ourselves – our strengths and weaknesses. It's about recognizing that our accomplishments are not solely our own doing, but are often supported by a larger framework, be it community, family, or divine grace. When we are humble, we are more receptive to guidance and less prone to arrogance, allowing us to be shaped by experiences and to learn from others.

Trusting in Divine Providence, Even When Unseen

The narrative emphasizes God's active involvement. God knew Saul before Samuel did, and God orchestrated their meeting. This underscores the principle of divine providence – the belief that God is at work in the world, guiding events, and preparing individuals for their roles. For us, this means cultivating faith that even when we don't see the full picture, or when our efforts seem futile, there is a larger plan unfolding. It encourages us to act with integrity and purpose, trusting that our efforts, offered with sincerity, are part of something greater. When we face uncertainty or setbacks, we can draw strength from the knowledge that we are not alone, and that our lives have a divinely guided trajectory.

The Transformation of the "Heart"

The text states, "God gave him another heart." This is a powerful metaphor for spiritual transformation. It suggests that our inner disposition, our motivations, and our very way of perceiving the world can be divinely influenced and renewed. This can happen through prayer, study, acts of kindness, and by actively seeking connection with the Divine. It's a reminder that true change comes not just from external circumstances, but from an internal reorientation. For us, this means actively cultivating positive inner qualities – compassion, resilience, wisdom – and being open to the ways in which we can be spiritually transformed.

One Thing to Remember

The key takeaway from this foundational story is that God's call to purpose often begins with the ordinary, and true leadership is marked by humility and receptivity to divine guidance. Look for the extraordinary within your everyday.