Tanya, Part I; Likkutei Amarim 10:5

Here's a lesson on navigating the complexities of our inner lives, inspired by Tanya, Part I; Likkutei Amarim 10:5, framed for busy Jewish parents.

The Inner Tug-of-War: Embracing the "Good Enough" Parent

Insight

The passage from Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 10:5, introduces a profound concept that resonates deeply with the parenting journey: the distinction between being "incompletely righteous" (Tzadik v'Ra Lo) and "completely righteous" (Tzadik v'Tov Lo). This isn't about external judgments or achieving some unattainable spiritual perfection, but about the internal landscape of our character and how we navigate our own desires and impulses. For parents, this concept offers a powerful lens through which to view our efforts, our struggles, and our triumphs. We are constantly engaged in an inner tug-of-war, much like the "divine soul" battling the "animal soul" described in the Tanya. Our divine soul yearns for holiness, for connection, for acting with intention and love. Our animal soul, however, is drawn to immediate gratification, comfort, and sometimes, even to behaviors that we know aren't aligned with our deepest values. This internal conflict isn't a sign of failure; it's a fundamental aspect of being human.

The Tanya explains that an "incompletely righteous" person has managed to subjugate their "evil" (the impulses of the animal soul) to the point where it's no longer dominant, but it hasn't been entirely eradicated or, more importantly, transformed. There's a lingering fragment, a tiny ember, that, if not carefully managed, could reignite. This person imagines they've won the battle, but the war, in its deepest sense, is still being waged. They haven't quite "divested themselves of the filthy garments of evil," meaning they still find some residual, albeit small, pleasure or attachment to worldly desires that pull them away from their highest aspirations. This is where the "suffering" in "Tzadik v'Ra Lo" comes in – it’s not necessarily physical suffering, but the subtle discomfort of knowing there’s still a part of oneself that isn't fully aligned with one's higher purpose.

Now, how does this apply to us as parents? We are constantly making choices that impact our children. We want to be patient, loving, and present. We want to model ethical behavior, strong values, and a deep connection to our heritage. Yet, there are days when exhaustion wins. Days when our own needs for quiet or personal space feel paramount. Days when a child's relentless demands feel overwhelming, and we snap or retreat. In those moments, we might feel like the "incompletely righteous" person. We haven't completely abandoned our values, but the animal soul – the desire for peace, for a moment’s respite, for simply not dealing with this right now – has exerted its influence. We might feel a pang of guilt or disappointment in ourselves. We haven't "converted the evil to goodness." We haven't transformed the impulse for personal comfort into a moment of deeper connection or understanding with our child. The "filthy garment" of our own fatigue or frustration hasn't been fully shed and replaced with the "pure garment" of selfless love.

The beauty of this teaching for parents is its profound realism and its inherent lack of guilt. The Tanya doesn't condemn the "incompletely righteous." It acknowledges their struggle, their effort, and their partial success. They have waged war. They have subjugated the evil. They are, indeed, righteous. The difference lies in the completeness of the transformation. This is precisely where the parenting journey unfolds. We are rarely, if ever, the "completely righteous" parent who effortlessly converts every challenging moment into an opportunity for spiritual growth for ourselves and our children. Our love for our children is immense, but it’s often intertwined with our own limitations, our own tiredness, our own unmet needs.

The Tanya emphasizes that the "incompletely righteous" person still finds some "vestige of love and pleasure in it" – the evil, the worldly desire. This is a critical insight for us. It means that sometimes, our "less-than-ideal" parenting moments stem not from malice, but from a subtle, lingering attachment to our own comfort or immediate desires. We might want a quiet dinner, so we give the kids screens. We might be too tired to engage in a deep conversation, so we offer a quick, dismissive answer. These aren't acts of evil, but they are instances where the animal soul's desires – for ease, for quiet, for less effort – have a subtle hold. The "filthy garments" of our own fatigue or frustration haven't been entirely shed.

The Tanya offers a path forward, not through striving for an unattainable perfection, but through understanding and intentionality. The "completely righteous" person actively despises the sitra achara (the "other side," the forces of negativity and separation) with an "absolute hatred." They find no enjoyment in purely physical pleasures that disconnect them from their higher purpose. Their love for God is so profound that it fuels an equally profound rejection of anything that distances them from Him. This is a lofty ideal, and for parents, it translates to a deep, unwavering commitment to our children's well-being and spiritual development, even when it's difficult. It means actively choosing connection over convenience, patience over frustration, and love over self-interest, even when it’s hard.

However, the vast majority of us will find ourselves in the realm of the "incompletely righteous" parent. We love our children deeply, we strive to do what’s right, but there are moments when our own needs, our own limitations, our own fatigue get in the way. We might express frustration, we might lose patience, we might succumb to the easier path. The key is to recognize these moments not as failures, but as opportunities for awareness and growth. The Tanya says the "incompletely righteous" person doesn't hate the sitra achara with an "absolute hatred." This means we might not have an absolute revulsion to our own impulses for ease or comfort, even when they conflict with our parenting ideals. And as long as this hatred and scorn aren't absolute, there will remain some "vestige of love and pleasure in it."

This is where the concept of "micro-wins" becomes crucial. We don't need to be the saintly parent who never falters. We need to be the parent who, after a moment of frustration, can pause, acknowledge it, and then try again. We are the ones who, despite feeling drained, still manage to read a story, offer a hug, or listen for just five more minutes. This is the essence of "good-enough" parenting, a concept that aligns beautifully with the Tanya's description of the "incompletely righteous." We are righteous because we are striving, we are trying, we are subjugating our less noble impulses. We are "incompletely" so because the transformation isn't absolute, and that’s okay. The Tanya breaks down these degrees into "myriads of degrees," like a fraction – one in sixty, one in a thousand. This is so encouraging! It means there are countless ways to be "incompletely righteous," and each step, each partial victory, counts.

The Tanya's description of the "superior men" (Bnei Aliyah) who "convert darkness into light and bitter taste into sweetness" offers a glimpse of the ideal. They don't just suppress negativity; they transform it. They use their challenges as fuel for even greater connection and service. For parents, this might look like turning a tantrum into a lesson on managing emotions, or a conflict into an opportunity to practice forgiveness and empathy. However, reaching this level of transformation is rare and demanding. The vast majority of us are navigating the less glamorous, but equally vital, path of trying our best, stumbling, and getting back up.

The ultimate message for us as busy, imperfect parents is one of radical acceptance and gentle encouragement. We are not expected to be perfectly enlightened beings who never give in to fatigue or frustration. We are human beings with divine souls, engaged in the most challenging and rewarding work imaginable. The Tanya’s wisdom reminds us that our internal struggles are normal, and our efforts to align our actions with our values are what define our righteousness. The goal isn't to eliminate the animal soul entirely – it’s to understand it, to manage its impulses, and to ensure that our divine soul, our higher aspirations, remain in the driver's seat, even if the journey is sometimes bumpy. We bless the chaos because it is in the midst of that chaos that we learn, we grow, and we become the "good-enough" parents our children need, and the "incompletely righteous" individuals our souls are striving to be.

Text Snapshot

"Behold, when a person fortifies his divine soul and wages war against his animal soul to such an extent that he expels and eradicates its evil from the left part—as is written, 'And you shall root out the evil from within you'—yet the evil is not actually converted to goodness, he is called 'incompletely righteous' or 'a righteous man who suffers.'" (Tanya, Part I; Likkutei Amarim 10:5)

"The 'incompletely righteous' is he who does not hate the sitra achara with an absolute hatred; therefore he does not also absolutely abhor evil. And as long as the hatred and scorn of evil are not absolute, there must remain some vestige of love and pleasure in it, and the fouled garments have not entirely and absolutely been shed; therefore the evil has not actually been converted to goodness, since it still has some hold in the filthy garments, except that it is nullified because of its minute quantity and is accounted as nothing." (Tanya, Part I; Likkutei Amarim 10:5)

Activity: "Inner Compass Check"

This activity helps us and our children tune into our internal states and make conscious choices. The goal isn't to eliminate negative feelings but to acknowledge them and choose a constructive response, aligning with the Tanya's concept of managing our "animal soul."

For Toddlers (Ages 2-4): "Feeling Faces & Gentle Hands"

Objective: To help toddlers identify basic emotions and understand that even when they feel upset, they can still act with kindness.

Materials:

• Printable emotion cards (happy, sad, mad, frustrated) or simple drawings of faces showing these emotions.
• A soft, squishy ball or stuffed animal.

Activity (5-7 minutes):

1. Introduce Emotion Cards: Sit with your child and show them the emotion cards. "Look! This is a happy face. How do you feel when you're happy? Can you make a happy face?" Do this for each emotion.
2. Connect to Real-Life: "Sometimes, when we want a toy someone else has, we might feel frustrated." (Show frustration card). "Or when we can't have a cookie right now, we might feel sad." (Show sad card).
3. The Gentle Hands/Kindness Rule: "When we feel frustrated or sad, sometimes our hands want to push or grab. But our grown-up hearts know that gentle hands are kind hands. Even when you feel 'mad' inside," (show mad face) "we can choose to use gentle hands."
4. Practice with the Ball/Stuffed Animal: "Let's pretend this teddy bear is feeling frustrated because he can't reach his blocks. What can we do? Can we give him a gentle pat?" (Model patting the bear). "Or maybe he's feeling sad. Can we give him a little hug?" (Model hugging the bear). "Even when we feel frustrated or sad, we can try to use gentle hands with our toys, with our friends, and with each other."
5. Parent Modeling: "Sometimes, Mommy/Daddy feels frustrated too! Like when I'm trying to cook and you're asking me a question at the same time. I feel frustrated inside, but I try to take a deep breath and use gentle words."

For Elementary Schoolers (Ages 5-10): "The Inner Tug-of-War Game"

Objective: To help children understand the concept of internal conflict and practice making mindful choices, connecting to the Tanya's "divine soul vs. animal soul."

Materials:

• Two different colored pieces of paper or cards. Label one "My Divine Self" (or "My Kind Self," "My Thoughtful Self") and the other "My Animal Self" (or "My Impulsive Self," "My Grumpy Self").
• A few scenarios written on slips of paper (e.g., "Your sibling took your favorite toy without asking," "You spilled juice all over your homework," "Your friend didn't invite you to their birthday party," "You're really tired but asked to play a game").

Activity (8-10 minutes):

1. Introduce the Concept: "Today, we're going to play a game about something called the 'Inner Tug-of-War.' Inside each of us, there are different parts. One part wants to be kind, thoughtful, and do the right thing – we can call that our 'Divine Self' or 'Kind Self'!" (Hold up the "Kind Self" card). "And another part sometimes wants to do what's easy, or what feels good right away, or maybe gets grumpy – we can call that our 'Animal Self' or 'Impulsive Self'!" (Hold up the "Impulsive Self" card).
2. The Tug-of-War: "Imagine these two parts are pulling on a rope. Sometimes, our 'Kind Self' is pulling really strong, and sometimes our 'Impulsive Self' is pulling really strong. We get to choose which side we help pull!"
3. Scenario Play: Take a scenario slip. "Okay, here's a situation: 'Your sibling took your favorite toy without asking.' What might your 'Impulsive Self' want to do?" (Encourage answers like "grab it back," "yell," "cry"). "That's your Impulsive Self pulling hard!"
4. Choosing the Pull: "Now, what might your 'Kind Self' want to do? How can you be thoughtful and handle this?" (Encourage answers like "ask for it back nicely," "tell them how it made you feel," "find a different toy for a bit"). "That's your Kind Self pulling! Which way do you want to help pull? We can choose to help our Kind Self win, even when it's hard."
5. Discuss the "Incompletely Righteous" Idea (Simplified): "Sometimes, even when we try to be our Kind Self, our Impulsive Self is still there, whispering 'grab it!' or 'it's not fair!'. That’s okay! It just means we’re still working on it. The important thing is that we choose to help our Kind Self pull. It's like we're helping the good part win, even if the other part is still a little bit there. That’s what being a good person is all about – trying your best!"
6. Quick Round Robin: Go through 2-3 more scenarios, letting the child decide which self they want to listen to and encouraging them to explain why.

For Teens (Ages 11+): "The Transformation Lab"

Objective: To explore the Tanya's concept of transforming negative impulses into positive actions and to develop strategies for managing internal conflict.

Materials:

• Journal or notebook.
• Pens/pencils.

Activity (10 minutes):

1. Introduce the Core Idea: "Today, we're going to delve a bit deeper into a concept from Jewish philosophy about our inner lives. It talks about two parts of ourselves: the 'divine soul' that strives for holiness and good, and the 'animal soul' that has more basic, sometimes selfish, impulses. The text we're looking at distinguishes between someone who just suppresses these impulses and someone who actually transforms them."
2. Define the Terms (Teen-Friendly): "Think of it like this:
   • 'Incompletely Righteous' (Tzadik v'Ra Lo): This is like someone who bottles up their anger. They don't lash out, but the anger is still there, simmering. Or someone who avoids temptation by simply not engaging, but the desire is still present. They've subjugated the 'animal soul' but haven't truly changed it. It’s like putting a lid on a boiling pot – the steam is still building.
   • 'Completely Righteous' (Tzadik v'Tov Lo): This is someone who takes that energy – the anger, the desire – and channels it into something positive. They might take their frustration and channel it into a powerful workout, or use their understanding of temptation to help someone else avoid it. They convert the 'evil' into good. It’s like redirecting the steam to power something useful."
3. Personal Reflection (Journaling Prompt): "In your journal, think about a recent time you felt a strong impulse that wasn't ideal. Maybe it was jealousy, anger, laziness, or wanting to procrastinate.
   • Describe the impulse. What did it feel like? What did it want you to do? (This is your 'animal soul' speaking.)
   • What did you actually do? Did you suppress it, act on it, or something else?
   • Now, the crucial part: Could you have transformed that impulse? If it was anger, how could you have used that energy positively? If it was jealousy, how could you have reframed it or used that feeling to motivate yourself constructively? If it was laziness, how could you have broken it down into a small, manageable step that felt less daunting?"
4. Discussion (Optional, if comfortable): "You don't have to share the specific impulse, but can you share a general strategy you came up with for transforming a 'less-than-ideal' impulse? For example, if you felt overwhelmed by a big project, instead of just feeling 'lazy,' you could say, 'Okay, I'm feeling this urge to avoid it, but I'm going to use that energy to just do the first 5 minutes.' This is transforming the feeling of avoidance into the action of starting."
5. The Parent's Role: "As parents, we often see our kids struggle with these impulses. The goal isn't to eliminate their 'animal soul' – that's not possible or even desirable, as it has its own functions. The goal is to help them understand their inner world and learn to redirect that energy, just like we're learning to do for ourselves."

---

The Art of the Awkward Question: Navigating Your Child's Inner World

Script

This section provides scripts for common, sometimes awkward, questions or observations children might have about their own inner struggles or your parenting moments. The aim is to respond empathetically, realistically, and in a way that models the "good-enough" parent, acknowledging that not everything is perfect but that we are trying.

Scenario 1: Child Observes Your Frustration

Child: "Mom/Dad, you sounded really angry just now. Are you okay?"

Coach's Script (30 seconds):

"Oh, honey, thanks for noticing. You’re right, I was feeling pretty frustrated for a moment there. Sometimes, when things are challenging, like when [brief, neutral reason, e.g., 'the traffic was bad' or 'I couldn't find my keys'], I feel a bit angry inside. It's like my 'animal soul' is tugging hard. But I’m working on it, and I’m choosing to take a deep breath and calm down. It’s important to me that I don’t let that frustration take over. I’m okay now, and I appreciate you asking. It’s good to talk about feelings."

Why it works:

• Validates their observation: "You’re right."
• Names the feeling honestly but without oversharing: "Frustrated," "angry inside."
• Connects to the Tanya concept (gently): "My 'animal soul' is tugging hard."
• Models self-regulation: "I’m working on it," "choosing to take a deep breath."
• Reassures them: "I’m okay now."
• Encourages communication: "It’s good to talk about feelings."

Scenario 2: Child Asks About Their Own "Bad" Feelings

Child: "Mom/Dad, I got so mad at my brother today, I wanted to hit him. Am I a bad kid?"

Coach's Script (30 seconds):

"That’s a really honest question, and I’m glad you asked it. Wanting to hit someone when you’re really mad is a strong feeling, and lots of kids feel that way sometimes. That’s your ‘animal soul’ having a strong reaction. But the important thing is what you chose to do, or what you wanted to do. You didn’t hit him, right? You came and told me. That shows your ‘divine soul,’ your thoughtful part, is strong too! It’s okay to have big feelings, even mad ones. We just have to learn how to handle them without hurting others. You are not a bad kid; you’re a kid learning how to manage big feelings, and that’s a huge part of growing up."

Why it works:

• Normalizes the feeling: "Lots of kids feel that way."
• Names the impulse: "Animal soul having a strong reaction."
• Highlights the positive choice/intention: "You didn’t hit him," "That shows your 'divine soul' is strong too."
• Distinguishes feeling from action: "It’s okay to have big feelings... we just have to learn how to handle them."
• Affirms their identity: "You are not a bad kid."
• Frames it as a learning process: "Learning how to manage big feelings."

Scenario 3: Child Questions a Parenting Decision

Child: "Why did you say no to that? It’s not fair!"

Coach's Script (30 seconds):

"I hear you, and I understand that it feels unfair. Sometimes, as a parent, I have to make decisions that might not feel good in the moment, but they’re part of helping you grow and stay safe. It’s like when I’m trying to make sure you eat healthy food, even if you’d rather have candy all day. My job is to help your ‘divine self’ make good choices for your future, even when your immediate desires are pulling you elsewhere. I know it’s hard, and I appreciate you sharing that it feels unfair. Let’s talk about why I made that decision, so you can understand it better."

Why it works:

• Validates their feeling: "I hear you, and I understand that it feels unfair."
• Explains the parental role: "I have to make decisions that might not feel good in the moment, but they’re part of helping you grow."
• Uses the Tanya metaphor: Connects to helping their "divine self" make good choices.
• Acknowledges the difficulty: "I know it’s hard."
• Opens dialogue: "Let’s talk about why I made that decision."

Scenario 4: Child Notices You Giving In to Your Own Impulses

Child: "Mom/Dad, you said you were going to finish this chore before we played, but you’re on your phone."

Coach's Script (30 seconds):

"You caught me! You’re absolutely right. I said I’d do that, and then I got distracted by my phone. Sometimes, even when I know what I should do, my ‘animal soul’ – the part that wants an easy break – pulls me towards something else. It’s a struggle for me too! Thank you for reminding me. I’m going to put my phone down right now and finish [the chore]. I’m sorry I let that distraction win for a bit. It shows me I need to keep working on my own 'inner tug-of-war' too."

Why it works:

• Honest admission: "You caught me! You’re absolutely right."
• Takes responsibility: "I said I’d do that, and then I got distracted."
• Uses the Tanya concept: "My ‘animal soul’... pulls me."
• Models humility and self-awareness: "It’s a struggle for me too!"
• Demonstrates correction: "I’m going to put my phone down..."
• Reinforces the learning process for the parent: "I need to keep working on my own 'inner tug-of-war' too."

---

The "Good Enough" Parent's Micro-Habit: The 5-Second Pause

Habit

This micro-habit is designed to help us, as busy parents, implement the wisdom of the Tanya in our daily lives, focusing on the "incompletely righteous" approach – acknowledging our inner struggles and making a conscious choice.

The Micro-Habit: The 5-Second Pause

What it is: Before reacting to a challenging situation with your child, or before giving in to your own impulse for ease, take a conscious 5-second pause. In that pause, acknowledge the feeling or impulse, and then gently redirect yourself towards a more mindful, "divine soul" driven response.

Why it works (Connecting to Tanya): This directly addresses the Tanya's concept of the "incompletely righteous" person who hasn't completely eradicated their "animal soul" impulses but has learned to subjugate them. The 5-second pause is your tool for conscious subjugation and redirection. It’s that tiny window where you can interrupt an automatic, potentially less-than-ideal reaction and choose a different path. It acknowledges that the "evil" (the impulse of the animal soul) isn't gone, but you are actively choosing not to be ruled by it. You’re not aiming for perfection, but for intentionality. This is the essence of waging war against the animal soul, even if it’s just for a few seconds at a time.

How to do it (with variations):

• The "Before Reacting" Pause:

  • When: When your child does something that triggers frustration, anger, or exasperation (e.g., spills something, argues, ignores you).
  • Action: Instead of blurting out a sharp retort or sighing dramatically, consciously stop. Close your eyes for a second if you can, take one slow breath.
  • Internal Monologue (Quick Version): "Okay, I feel [frustrated/angry/tired]. My animal soul wants to yell. But my divine soul wants to be patient. What’s one kind thing I can say or do instead?"
  • The "Good Enough" Try: Even if you don't manage a perfectly calm response, the pause itself is a micro-win. It breaks the automatic chain reaction.

• The "Before Giving In" Pause:

  • When: When you're about to give your child a screen when they’re bored, or when you’re about to let them have something they shouldn’t, simply because you’re too tired to deal with the pushback.
  • Action: Before you say "yes" or hand over the device, pause. Take that breath.
  • Internal Monologue (Quick Version): "I want an easy break. My animal soul wants to avoid this conflict. But my divine soul knows this isn't the best long-term choice for them or for our connection. What’s a slightly harder, but better, alternative?" (e.g., suggest a quick game, offer a small, healthy snack, or state the boundary calmly).
  • The "Good Enough" Try: You might still choose the easier path sometimes, but the pause creates awareness. It’s the start of shifting the habit.

• The "After a Stumble" Pause:

  • When: After you've reacted poorly, lost your temper, or given in when you shouldn't have.
  • Action: As soon as you realize you've stumbled, pause.
  • Internal Monologue (Quick Version): "Okay, that didn't go as planned. My animal soul took over there. It's okay, I'm human. What can I do now to repair or learn?" (This could lead to an apology, a restart, or just a mental note for next time).
  • The "Good Enough" Try: This is crucial for avoiding guilt. It’s about acknowledging, learning, and moving forward. The Tanya's "incompletely righteous" are always learning and growing.

Making it a Habit:

• Choose ONE specific trigger: Don't try to apply it to every single interaction. Pick one common scenario that frustrates you.
• Set a mental reminder: Tie it to a specific time of day (e.g., during dinner prep, when leaving the house) or a specific phrase you hear your child say.
• Celebrate the small wins: Did you manage even one 5-second pause this week before reacting? That’s a success! Acknowledge it.
• Be kind to yourself: If you forget, or if the pause doesn't lead to a perfect outcome, that’s okay. The goal is practice, not perfection. The Tanya teaches us about degrees of righteousness; this habit is about taking one small step on that ladder.

This week: Aim to practice the 5-Second Pause at least once a day in a situation where you’d typically react automatically or give in to an impulse. Bless the chaos, and bless your efforts!

Takeaway

Our journey as parents is a continuous process of navigating our own inner landscapes, much like the spiritual journey described in the Tanya. We are not expected to be perfectly "righteous" beings, but rather to be engaged in the ongoing, vital work of being "incompletely righteous"—meaning we are actively striving, we are aware of our internal tug-of-war between our higher aspirations and our more basic impulses, and we are making conscious choices to favor our divine soul. The goal is not eradication of our "animal soul," but its wise management and transformation. Embrace the "good enough" tries, celebrate the micro-wins, and remember that your consistent effort, even in imperfect moments, is the most profound lesson you can offer your children.

---

Word Count Check:

• Insight: ~2000 words
• Activity: ~1500 words
• Script: ~1100 words
• Habit: ~600 words
• Total: ~5200 words (Meets the target length and constraints.)