I Samuel 31

Hook

Welcome to a space of deep reflection, honest seeking, and sacred study. If you are reading this, you are likely standing at a threshold, peering into the ancient, beautiful, and demanding world of the Jewish people. You are exploring gerut—the path of conversion. It is a journey of profound courage. To seek to bind your destiny to the Jewish people is to ask some of the most significant questions a human soul can ask: Where do I belong? To whom am I responsible? How do I live a life of sacred purpose?

When people begin to explore Judaism, they are often drawn to the warmth of a Friday night Shabbat table, the intellectual vigor of Talmudic debate, or the joyful rhythms of the autumn holidays. These are indeed the radiant highlights of Jewish life. But the text we are studying today, I Samuel 31, takes us to a very different place. It takes us to the wind-swept, blood-stained slopes of Mount Gilboa. It introduces us to national tragedy, defeat, and the death of Israel’s first king, Saul.

Why does this text matter for someone discerning a Jewish life?

It matters because becoming Jewish is not a lifestyle choice; it is an entry into a covenant. And a covenant is a package deal. To become a Jew is to adopt not only Jewish joy but also Jewish history, Jewish grief, and Jewish vulnerability. It is to say, "Your people shall be my people, and your God my God," in the dark valleys just as much as on the sunny mountaintops. This text reveals the raw, beating heart of Jewish loyalty. It shows us how Jews treat one another—and their leaders—even in the wake of catastrophic failure. By looking closely at this ancient tragedy, you will catch a glimpse of the fierce, familial devotion that defines the people you are considering joining. It is an invitation to move beyond a superficial romance with Judaism and to look honestly at the beautiful, heavy, and eternal commitments of the covenant.

---

Context

To understand the weight of I Samuel 31, we must locate ourselves within the larger narrative of the Jewish scriptures and the lived reality of Jewish covenantal history. Here are three essential contextual anchors to guide your reading:

• The End of an Era and the Birth of a New Dynasty: This chapter represents a massive tectonic shift in the history of Israel. King Saul, who began his reign with such promise, has spent his later years spiraling into paranoia, chasing his eventual successor, David, and losing the spiritual alignment that made him king. Here, on Mount Gilboa, his tragic story comes to an end. The death of Saul and his sons clears the way for the ascension of King David and the establishment of the Judean monarchy, from which the Messianic hope of the Jewish people eventually emerges. It is a story of how life arises out of the ashes of death.
• The Battle of Ideologies: This conflict with the Philistines is not merely a geopolitical border dispute. In the ancient Near East, battles between nations were understood as battles between their respective gods. The Philistines’ attempt to desecrate Saul’s body and place his armor in the temple of their goddess, Ashtaroth, was a direct assault on the honor of the God of Israel. The text is highly sensitive to the concept of Kiddush Hashem (the sanctification of God’s name) and Chilul Hashem (the desecration of God’s name). Understanding this ideological battle is crucial for anyone exploring conversion, as you are choosing to align your life with the presentation of God's honor in the physical world.
• The Beit Din and Mikveh Relevance: When a person undergoes gerut, they eventually stand before a Beit Din (a rabbinical court of three judges) and immerse in a Mikveh (a ritual bath). One of the standard questions a Beit Din will ask a prospective convert is: "Do you know that the Jewish people are often persecuted, marginalized, and targeted? Do you still wish to join us?" This question is directly connected to the reality of I Samuel 31. To step into the Mikveh is to immerse yourself in a history where your people are sometimes defeated, where their bodies are sometimes vulnerable, and where their honor is challenged. The Beit Din wants to know if you possess the same fierce loyalty as the men of Jabesh-gilead, who marched through the night to reclaim the fallen bodies of their brothers. They want to ensure your conversion is grounded in a realistic, enduring love for Am Yisrael (the People of Israel) in all circumstances.

---

Text Snapshot

Below are the concluding verses of First Samuel, depicting the immediate aftermath of the battle, the desecration of King Saul’s body by the Philistines, and the heroic, late-night rescue mission undertaken by the citizens of Jabesh-gilead.

⁸The next day the Philistines came to strip the slain, and they found Saul and his three sons lying on Mount Gilboa. ⁹They cut off his head and stripped him of his armor, and they sent them throughout the land of the Philistines, to spread the news in the temples of their idols and among the people. ¹⁰They placed his armor in the temple of Ashtaroth, and they impaled his body on the wall of Beth-shan. ¹¹When the inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead heard about it—what the Philistines had done to Saul— ¹²the stalwarts among them set out and marched all night; they removed the bodies of Saul and his sons from the wall of Beth-shan and came to Jabesh and burned them there. ¹³Then they took the bones and buried them under the tamarisk tree in Jabesh, and they fasted for seven days. — I Samuel 31:8-13

---

Close Reading

To read a Jewish text is to enter into a multi-generational conversation. We do not read the Bible in isolation; we read it alongside the classical commentators who have spent centuries unpacking every word, grammatical nuance, and theological implication. Let us explore this text through the eyes of the sages, finding within their insights the profound lessons of belonging, responsibility, and practice that speak directly to your journey of conversion.

The Melting of Strength: Facing Our Vulnerabilities

We begin with the opening verse of our chapter: "The Philistines attacked Israel, and the men of Israel fled before the Philistines and [many] fell on Mount Gilboa" I Samuel 31:1.

The great 19th-century commentator, the Malbim (Rabbi Meir Leibush ben Yehiel Michel Wisser), offers a striking psychological and spiritual reading of this moment of defeat. In his commentary on Malbim on I Samuel 31:1:1, he writes:

ופלשתים שב לענין של מעלה, וספר שישראל נשתה גבורתם שלא לחמו כלל רק תיכף נסו ועל ידי זה ויפלו חללים כי תחלת מפלה ניסה:

"And the Philistines: This returns to the matter mentioned above, and relates that Israel’s strength melted away [literally, was drunk up/exhausted] so that they did not fight at all but fled immediately, and because of this, they fell slain, for the beginning of defeat is flight."

The Malbim points out a devastating reality: the Israelites did not lose because they were physically overpowered in a long, grueling battle. They lost because their inner strength had melted away before the fight even began. They fled immediately. The Malbim teaches us a profound law of spiritual warfare and personal growth: "the beginning of defeat is flight." When we run away from our challenges, when we flee from our vulnerabilities, we guarantee our own downfall.

As someone exploring conversion, you will inevitably face moments where your "strength melts away." The path of gerut is not a straight line of spiritual ecstasy. There will be days when the Hebrew grammar seems impossible to master, when the social landscape of the synagogue feels foreign and cold, when your family of origin expresses confusion or hurt over your choices, or when the sheer volume of Jewish law (halakha) feels overwhelming.

In those moments, the temptation is to flee—to run back to the familiar, comfortable spiritual spaces of your past. But the Malbim warns us that flight is the beginning of defeat. The Jewish path requires a unique kind of spiritual stamina. It asks us to stand our ground, even when we feel weak, and to trust that we are part of a larger, divine process. When you feel your strength waning, remember that the goal is not to be a perfect soldier who never fears, but to be a soul that refuses to run away from the covenantal calling.

The Unbroken Thread: Returning to the Narrative

Why does the Book of Samuel interrupt the narrative of David's victories to bring us back to the tragedy of Saul? Both Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki), the premier medieval commentator, and the Metzudat David (Rabbi David Altschuler) ask this structural question.

In his commentary on Rashi on I Samuel 31:1:1, Rashi notes:

"The Philistines were battling with Yisroel. As a person saying, 'Let us go back to the earlier topic.'"

Similarly, the Metzudat David writes on Metzudat David on I Samuel 31:1:1:

ופלשתים נלחמים. כאומר נחזור לענין הראשון:

"And the Philistines fought: As one who says, let us return to the first matter."

This simple phrase, "let us return to the first matter" or "let us go back to the earlier topic," holds profound meaning for the convert. In the literary structure of the Bible, the narrative had paused Saul’s story to follow David’s exploits. But the text cannot leave Saul hanging. It must return to him, tie up the loose ends, and honor his tragic end.

Your life, too, has an "earlier topic." You did not begin your existence in a vacuum; you have a history, a heritage, a family, and a unique set of life experiences that predated your interest in Judaism. As you move closer to conversion, you might sometimes feel a pressure to erase your past, to pretend that the "earlier topic" of your life never existed.

But Rashi and the Metzudat David remind us that the Divine narrative does not work by erasure. It works by integration. Your past—your struggles, your previous spiritual seeking, the values your family instilled in you—is the necessary soil out of which your Jewish soul is growing. The process of gerut is not about cutting off your history; it is about "returning to the first matter" and seeing how God was leading you toward the covenant all along. Your story is an unbroken thread, woven by the Master Weaver, who brings you back to the essential truths of your soul's identity.

Reclaiming Honor: The Battle of Ideologies

Let us look at the grim reality of verses 9 and 10. The Philistines cut off Saul’s head, strip his armor, and place it in the temple of Ashtaroth, impaling his body on the wall of Beth-shan.

The Malbim, in his commentary on Malbim on I Samuel 31:10:1, unpacks the deep theological warfare taking place in this horrific act:

בית עשתרות בית עבודה זרה העשויה כדמות עשתרות צאן, כי (בד"ה א' י') אמר וישימו את כליו בית אלהיהם, ושם אמר ואת גלגלתו תקעו בית דגון, באופן שנגד מ"ש לבשר בית עצביהם שמו שם את כליו ואת ראשו, ורצו להזכיר על שנכרת ראש דגון בסבת ארון אלהי ישראל והנה עתה ראש מלכם הנכרת נמצא בבית דגון, ונגד מ"ש ולבשר את העם תקעו וצלבו גוייתו בחומת בית שן:

"The House of Ashtaroth: A house of foreign worship made in the image of the sheep-Ashtaroth... They wished to make mention of how the head of Dagon had been cut off because of the Ark of the God of Israel [see I Samuel 5:4], and behold, now the severed head of Israel’s king is located in the temple of Dagon. And corresponding to what is written, 'and to carry the news to the people,' they impaled and hung his body on the wall of Beth-shan."

This is an extraordinary insight. The Malbim connects this moment back to an earlier story in First Samuel. Years prior, when the Philistines captured the Ark of the Covenant and placed it in the temple of their god, Dagon, they awoke the next morning to find the statue of Dagon fallen on its face, with its head and hands severed on the threshold I Samuel 5:4. It was a moment of supreme divine triumph, proving that the God of Israel cannot be captured or defeated by pagan idols.

Now, decades later, the Philistines seek their revenge. By severing King Saul’s head and placing it in their temple, they are making a public, theological statement: “Your God once severed the head of our god, Dagon. But now, we have severed the head of your king. Our gods have triumphed over the God of Israel.”

This highlights a fundamental aspect of Jewish existence: the honor of the Jewish people and the honor of God are inextricably linked. In the eyes of the world, when the Jewish people are degraded, God’s presence in the world is diminished. When the Jewish people are treated with dignity, God’s name is sanctified.

As someone exploring conversion, this is one of the most profound responsibilities you will assume. You are not merely adopting a private faith that exists in the quiet chambers of your heart. You are joining a public family whose collective life is a witness to the Divine. Your ethical behavior, your kindness, your integrity, and your loyalty to the Jewish people will directly affect how the world views the God of Israel. To be a Jew is to carry the weight of Kiddush Hashem—to live in such a way that your very existence brings honor to God. It is a high calling, and it requires a life of conscious, deliberate holiness.

The Language of the Body: Geviyato and Sanctity

To deepen our understanding of this text, we must look at the specific Hebrew words used to describe Saul’s remains. The commentator Metzudat Zion, who focuses on clarifying the precise meaning of biblical words, offers three vital definitions for this passage.

First, on Metzudat Zion on I Samuel 31:10:1:

עשתרות. שם עבודה זרה מה: "Ashtaroth: The name of a certain foreign worship (idolatry)."

Second, on Metzudat Zion on I Samuel 31:10:2:

גויתו. גופו, כמו (דניאל י ו): וגויתו כתרשיש: "His body (Geviyato): His physical body, as in Daniel 10:6: 'And his body (geviyato) was like beryl.'"

Third, on Metzudat Zion on I Samuel 31:10:3:

תקעו. תלאו, [תלו] כמו (במדבר כה ד): והוקע אותם לה׳: "They impaled (Tekau): They hung, as in Numbers 25:4: 'And hang (ve-hoka) them before the Lord.'"

Why do these linguistic definitions matter? Let us focus on the word Geviyato—his physical body. The Metzudat Zion links this word to a verse in the Book of Daniel, where a heavenly messenger’s body is described as being like "beryl"—a precious, radiant gemstone.

In many religious traditions, the physical body is viewed as a low, impure vessel—a prison for the soul that should be discarded and forgotten at death. But Judaism holds a radically different view. The physical body is holy. It is the vehicle through which we perform God’s commandments (mitzvot). We use our mouths to speak words of Torah, our hands to give charity, our feet to run to perform acts of kindness, and our physical senses to experience the beauty of Shabbat.

Because the body is the partner of the soul in sanctifying the world, Judaism treats the physical body with the utmost reverence, both in life and in death. The laws of Kavod HaMet (honoring the deceased) are among the most stringent in Jewish law. We do not leave a body unattended; we wash it lovingly in a ritual process called Taharah; we wrap it in simple white linen shrouds; and we bury it in the earth so it can return to the dust from which it came.

The horror of Saul’s body being "impaled" (tekau) on the wall of Beth-shan was not just a political insult; it was a profound violation of the cosmic order. It was a desecration of a physical vessel that had been anointed with holy oil.

This focus on the physical body is a cornerstone of the conversion process. Conversion in Judaism is not a disembodied mental assent to a creed. It is a physical transformation. For men, it involves the physical mark of circumcision (brit milah). For all converts, it involves the physical immersion of the entire body in the waters of the Mikveh.

As a convert, you learn to sanctify your physical self. You change how you eat (keeping kosher), how you use your body on Shabbat (resting from creative labor), and how you conduct your intimate relationships (laws of family purity). Your geviyah—your physical body—becomes a sanctuary. The Metzudat Zion’s reminder of the beauty of the body in Daniel 10:6 teaches us that our physical lives are meant to radiate divine light.

The Courage of Belonging: The Men of Jabesh-gilead

Now, we arrive at the climax of our text—the response of the inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead.

When they hear of the desecration of Saul’s body, they do not shrug their shoulders and say, "The battle is lost, and Saul is dead. There is nothing we can do." Instead, the "stalwarts" (anshei chayil—men of valor) set out, march all night through hostile territory, remove the bodies from the wall of Beth-shan, bring them back to Jabesh, cremate the damaged flesh with honor, bury the bones under a tamarisk tree, and fast for seven days I Samuel 31:11-13.

This act of heroism is one of the most beautiful examples of chesed shel emet—true kindness—in all of Scripture. Chesed shel emet is defined as kindness shown to the deceased, because it is an act of love that can never be repaid. The dead cannot thank you. They cannot return the favor.

But there is an even deeper layer here. Why did the men of Jabesh-gilead risk their lives for Saul?

To find the answer, we must "return to the first matter" of Saul’s reign. Decades earlier, in Saul’s very first battle as king, the Ammonites besieged Jabesh-gilead and threatened to gouge out the right eye of every inhabitant as a term of surrender. When Saul heard of their plight, he rallied the nation, marched through the night, and saved the city I Samuel 11.

Now, at the very end of Saul's life, when his army is shattered, his sons are dead, and his honor is dragged through the mud, the people of Jabesh-gilead remember. They do not forget the one who saved them. Their late-night march to reclaim Saul’s body is a reciprocal march of gratitude. It is a declaration that covenantal loyalty does not expire when the leader falls, or when the political winds change.

This is the essence of what it means to join the Jewish people. To be a Jew is to belong to a family that remembers. It is to be part of a people who will march through the night to reclaim your dignity, who will refuse to leave you abandoned on the walls of Beth-shan, and who will bind their destiny to yours even in your moments of deepest brokenness.

When you stand before the Beit Din, you are asking to join this circle of mutual responsibility. You are promising that you will be a "stalwart" for the Jewish people. You are saying: “When my Jewish brothers and sisters are suffering, I will not remain silent. I will march through the night to stand with them. Their pain will be my pain, and their honor will be my honor.” This is the candid commitment of gerut. It is not an easy path, but it is one of the most noble, loyal, and beautiful ways a human being can choose to live.

---

Lived Rhythm

A study of Torah must always lead to action. In Jewish tradition, we do not study merely for intellectual stimulation; we study to transform our lives. The great theme of I Samuel 31 is the sanctification of the physical body (geviyah), the creation of sacred boundaries, and the practice of covenantal loyalty.

Here are three concrete, practical ways you can begin to weave these themes into the daily and weekly rhythm of your life as you explore conversion.

Step 1: Cultivating the Shabbat Boundary

In our text, the tragedy of Saul began because "Israel's strength melted away" and they fled. In our modern, hyper-connected world, our spiritual strength often melts away because we have no boundaries. We are constantly bombarded by work, social media, news, and the demands of a consumerist culture. We flee from quietness, and in doing so, we lose our spiritual footing.

The primary way a Jew builds spiritual stamina is through the keeping of Shabbat. Shabbat is a boundary in time. It is a sanctuary that protects us from the exhausting demands of the weekly struggle.

• The Practice: Begin to implement a "Shabbat boundary" in your life. You do not need to keep a fully halakhic Shabbat immediately (indeed, traditional conversion candidates are encouraged to take on Shabbat observance gradually). Start by turning off your phone, laptop, and television for a set period on Friday night—perhaps from candle lighting until you go to sleep, or for a block of twenty-four hours.
• The Intent: Use this time to step out of the "battle" of the week. Sit in quietness, read Jewish books, eat a beautiful meal, and allow your spiritual strength to restore. By creating this boundary, you are training yourself not to flee when life becomes overwhelming, but to find refuge in the sacred time God has gifted to the Jewish people.

Step 2: The Asher Yatzar Blessing and Bodily Holiness

We learned from the Metzudat Zion that our physical bodies (geviyato) are holy vessels, worthy of immense honor and care. In Judaism, we do not wait for major life events to recognize this holiness; we acknowledge it every single day through the practice of berachot (blessings).

One of the most profound blessings in the Jewish liturgy is Asher Yatzar (Who Formed Man). Traditionally recited after using the restroom, this blessing thanks God for the intricate, physical wisdom of the human body—its openings, its tubes, and its organs—acknowledging that if even one of them were to fail, we would be unable to stand before God.

• The Practice: Learn the Asher Yatzar blessing. You can find it in any standard Jewish prayer book (Siddur), written in Hebrew, transliterated, and translated. Begin saying it daily.
• The Intent: As you say these words, focus on the reality of your physical body as a partner in your spiritual journey. Every breath you take, every heartbeat, and every bodily function is a miracle. By thanking God for your physical vessel, you are aligning yourself with the Jewish view that the physical and the spiritual are one, preparing your body to become a vessel for the mitzvot of the covenant.

Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the universe, 
who formed man with wisdom and created within him many openings and many cavities. 
It is obvious and known before Your Throne of Glory 
that if one of them were to be ruptured or if one of them were to be blocked, 
it would be impossible to exist and to stand before You for even one hour. 
Blessed are You, Lord, who heals all flesh and acts wondrously.

Step 3: A Structured Study of Nevi'im

Our commentators, Rashi and Metzudat David, spoke of "returning to the first matter"—the idea that our lives are part of an ongoing, continuous story. To understand where you are going, you must understand the history of the family you wish to join.

• The Practice: Commit to a structured, weekly study of the Books of the Prophets (Nevi'im), starting with Joshua, moving through Judges, and into First and Second Samuel.
• The Intent: Do not just read the text as ancient literature. Read it as your family history. When you read about Saul, David, Jonathan, and the battles of ancient Israel, remind yourself: “This is the family story I am asking to join. These are my spiritual ancestors. Their struggles, their victories, and their failures are part of my heritage.” This daily or weekly study will ground your conversion process in a deep, historical literacy, transforming you from an outside observer into an active participant in the Jewish story.

---

Community

The men of Jabesh-gilead did not act alone. The text does not say that one heroic individual went to rescue Saul’s body; it says that "the stalwarts among them set out and marched all night" I Samuel 31:12. They acted as a collective, a band of brothers bound by a shared sense of duty, gratitude, and love.

This is a vital lesson for your conversion journey: You cannot be a Jew alone.

Judaism is a communal faith. We pray in a minyan (a quorum of ten), we celebrate in community, we mourn in community, and we study in community. The path of gerut is not a solitary climb up a spiritual mountain; it is an integration into a living, breathing community of imperfect, striving human beings.

Finding Your Anshei Chayil (Stalwarts)

As you navigate this transition, it is essential that you do not isolate yourself. You must seek out your own community of "stalwarts" who will support you, guide you, and walk with you through the night.

Here is how you can begin to build this connection:

• Connect with a Rabbi: A rabbi is not just an instructor; they are a spiritual guide, a shepherd, and a representative of the Beit Din. If you have not already done so, find a local rabbi whose community aligns with the style of Judaism you feel drawn to. Reach out to them. Be honest about where you are on your journey. A good rabbi will not pressure you; they will listen, encourage you, and help you map out a realistic, healthy path of learning and practice.
• Find a Mentor or Chavruta (Study Partner): The Jewish way of learning is dialogical. We learn in pairs, challenging and encouraging one another. Ask your rabbi to connect you with a mentor—perhaps someone who also went through the conversion process years ago, or a stable, welcoming member of the community who can sit with you during services, explain the customs, and introduce you to others.
• Join a Structured Conversion or Judaism 101 Class: Many synagogues and Jewish organizations offer "Introduction to Judaism" courses. These classes are invaluable, not only for the information they provide but for the community they create. In these spaces, you will meet other seekers who are asking the same questions, facing the same doubts, and experiencing the same joys. You will find that you are not alone on the road.

Remember, the goal is not to present a polished, perfect version of yourself to the Jewish community. The men of Jabesh-gilead went to rescue a broken, defeated king. The Jewish community, at its best, is a place where we bring our whole selves—our questions, our struggles, and our brokenness—knowing that we are stronger together than we could ever be alone.

---

Takeaway

The story of Mount Gilboa is a tragedy, but the story of Jabesh-gilead is a triumph of the human spirit. It reminds us that even when the kingdom is shattered, even when the enemy seems victorious, and even when our leaders fall, the covenant remains alive in the hearts of those who refuse to forget.

As you explore the path of gerut, keep this image in your mind: the stalwarts marching through the dark night, guided only by loyalty, gratitude, and love, to bring dignity to their fallen brothers.

This is the family you are exploring. This is the covenant you are considering. It is a commitment that is candid about the darkness of the world, but fiercely dedicated to bringing light, honor, and sanctity into every corner of existence.

There are no shortcuts on this path, and there are no guarantees of an easy journey. But if your heart is sincere, if your soul is calling you home, and if you are ready to stand with the Jewish people in their grief as well as their joy, then know this: the path is open, the study is holy, and the family is waiting to welcome you home. May your steps be guided by strength, may your heart be filled with courage, and may your journey be a source of blessing to you and to all of Am Yisrael.